01
Best overall pick
JoJo's Pizza
Village Center In Thurston • Small-Town Pizzeria And Sub Shop • Local Favorite
The classic Thurston stop for a loaded pie, wings, and a box of leftovers to take home.
JoJo's feels like the kind of place every small town needs: big portions, friendly staff, and pizza that leans hearty over fussy. The crust runs on the thicker, chewier side, with plenty of cheese and toppings that actually cover the slice. It is the go-to for a Friday night carryout order when you want something close, reliable, and filling.
02
Best lakeside stop
Pizza Cottage
Near Buckeye Lake • Lakeside Pizza Restaurant And Bar • Best For Game Nights
A long-running Buckeye Lake staple with crisp-edged pies, roomy booths, and plenty of TVs.
A short drive from Thurston, Pizza Cottage is where many locals head when they want pizza plus a night out. The menu covers thin and traditional crusts, loaded specialty pies, and shareable appetizers that suit a table of friends. It is especially popular on summer evenings, when lake traffic and big-screen sports give the dining room an easygoing buzz.
03
Neighborhood family go-to
Cristy's Pizza
Downtown Baltimore • Carryout Pizza Chain With Local Roots • Best For Families
A dependable nearby option for classic Ohio-style pizza, breadsticks, and kid-friendly combo deals.
Cristy's in Baltimore draws a steady stream of families who want something familiar, fast, and not too pricey. The pizzas skew toward a thinner crust with well-done edges, and the lineup of breadsticks and subs makes it easy to please picky eaters. With straightforward ordering and quick turnaround, it is ideal for weeknight dinners after practices or school events.
04
Hearty slice choice
Fat Cat Pizza
East Side Of Lancaster • Classic Midwestern Pizza Joint • Best For Big Appetites
Old-school, generously topped pies that eat like a full meal and then some.
Fat Cat Pizza is the place to go when you are not counting slices or calories. Expect thick layers of cheese, sturdy crust, and toppings that pile high, especially on their signature specialty combinations. It is a bit of a drive from Thurston, but the portions make it a smart pick when you are feeding a hungry group or planning for leftovers.
05
Lively night-out pick
Pizza Crossing
Historic Downtown Lancaster • Bustling Local Pizza House • Best For Lively Nights Out
A busy downtown spot known for its chewy crust, loaded toppings, and energetic dining room.
Pizza Crossing has earned a loyal following well beyond Lancaster, and it is worth the drive from Thurston when you want a bit more atmosphere. Pies come generously sauced and topped, with a crust that stays sturdy under the weight, making it great for sharing at the table. The steady flow of regulars, big families, and post-game teams gives the place a friendly, lived-in feel.