01
Best overall pick
Biga Wood Fired Pizzeria
Downtown Mentor • Cozy Wood-Fired Pizzeria • Destination For Pizza Purists
Neapolitan-style pies with charred, airy crusts make this Mentor spot a must for serious pizza fans.
Biga leans into a simple formula: a blazing-hot wood oven, thoughtfully sourced toppings, and dough that gets a perfect leopard-spotted char. The menu leans Italian, but the pizzas are the clear headliners, from classic Margherita to creative seasonal combinations. It’s an easy choice when you want something a notch more special than your standard takeout pie.
02
Best for hearty, classic pies
Bada Bing Pizza
Mentor-On-The-Lake • Casual Neighborhood Pizza Joint • Old-School Favorite
Generous toppings and a classic, crowd-pleasing crust make Bada Bing a go-to for sharing with friends and family.
Bada Bing is the kind of place locals keep on speed dial for Friday nights and game days. The crust lands in that sweet spot between thin and thick, sturdy enough to hold plenty of cheese and toppings without feeling heavy. Add in wings, subs, and reliable service and you’ve got a solid, no-drama option for feeding a group.
03
Best delivery to Timberlake
Rego's Brickhouse Pizza
Eastlake • Casual Brick-Oven Pizzeria • Delivery Standby
Reliable delivery, well-browned cheese, and sturdy slices make Rego's a natural pick when you want pizza brought to your door.
Rego's focuses on straightforward comfort: familiar toppings, a firm crust, and plenty of cheese baked to a deep golden edge. It’s especially handy for Timberlake residents thanks to fast delivery and consistent execution. When you don’t feel like cooking or driving but still want a satisfying pie, this is the move.
04
Best for carryout near the lake
Giuseppe's Pizza
Willowick Lakefront • Classic Takeout Pizzeria • Best For Quick Carryout
A long-running Willowick shop turning out classic pies, subs, and wings that travel well back to Timberlake.
Giuseppe's feels like the archetypal neighborhood pizza place, with a menu built around hand-tossed pies, big salads, and hearty subs. The pizzas hold up nicely in the box, making them great for a quick pickup on your way home along the lakeshore. It’s especially handy when you want an easy, familiar option that still tastes like a local spot.
05
Best family-style Italian spot
Longo's Pizza
South Mentor • Family-Run Italian Pizzeria • Family Favorite
Comforting red-sauce Italian dishes and shareable pizzas make Longo's a relaxed choice for family dinners.
Longo's combines classic pizzeria vibes with a full Italian menu, so everyone at the table can find something they like. The pizzas come with a slightly thicker, chewy crust and plenty of melty cheese, ideal for slicing up and passing around. Pair a pie with a pasta or salad, and you’ve got an easy, sit-down meal that’s still a quick hop from Timberlake.