01
Best overall pick
East of Chicago Pizza
Uhrichsville • Thick-Crust Carryout Chain • Great For Hearty Specialty Pies
A go-to for loaded, pan-style pizzas when you want serious cheese and toppings without driving far from Tippecanoe.
East of Chicago in Uhrichsville is one of the closest full-menu pizzerias to Tippecanoe, known for its thick, airy crust and generous toppings. Their specialty pizzas and buffet-style options make it easy to feed a crew after a day on the road or at the lake. Call ahead for carryout or delivery toward the eastern side of the county.
02
Best for classic Ohio-style pizza
Gionino's Pizzeria
New Philadelphia • Neighborhood Takeout Shop • Local Favorite For Crispy Crust
A regional Ohio chain with a strong local following, especially for its crispy crust and bold, garlicky flavors.
Gionino's in New Philadelphia is worth the drive from Tippecanoe if you like your pizza on the slightly crispy side with plenty of edge-to-edge toppings. Their signature garlic-heavy style and well-seasoned sauce set it apart from the national chains. Add an order of jojo potatoes and chicken if you are feeding a mixed crowd.
03
Closest sit-down option
Pizza Hut
Cadiz • Classic Dine-In Chain • Best For Families And Groups
A familiar, family-friendly spot in Cadiz for pan pizzas, pastas, and a relaxed sit-down meal.
For Tippecanoe locals who want a simple night out, the Pizza Hut in Cadiz offers the comfort of a full-service dining room with all the classics. The menu covers pan, hand-tossed, and thin-crust pies, so everyone at the table can get what they like. It is an easy choice when you want more than takeout boxes and a place to linger over dinner.
04
Best for fast delivery
Domino's Pizza
New Philadelphia • Quick-Service Delivery Shop • Best For Late-Night And Game Days
Reliable for quick delivery or carryout, with customizable pies and plenty of sides for game-day spreads.
Domino's in New Philadelphia is a practical option when convenience matters more than lingering over a meal. The online ordering and tracking make it easy to time your pickup as you pass through on the way back to Tippecanoe. With build-your-own pizzas, wings, and sandwiches, it is an easy crowd-pleaser for late-night snacks or last-minute plans.
05
Best budget-friendly stop
Little Caesars Pizza
New Philadelphia North Side • Grab-And-Go Takeout Spot • Best For Quick, Affordable Pies
A fast, low-cost choice with ready-made pizzas that are ideal for feeding a hungry group on the way home.
Little Caesars on the north side of New Philadelphia is all about speed and value, with its familiar Hot-N-Ready pies. It is a convenient stop if you are passing through town and need to pick up several pizzas without calling ahead. The straightforward menu and consistent pricing make it a dependable option for casual gatherings back in Tippecanoe.