01
Best overall pick
Home Slice Pizza
Warehouse District Downtown • Casual Two-Story Slice Shop And Bar • Best For Late-Night Slices
A lively downtown staple where you can grab a big, foldable slice and a drink well into the night.
Home Slice feels like the place everyone eventually ends up after a Mud Hens game or a night out in the Warehouse District. The first floor moves quickly for slices, while the upstairs bar is made for lingering with whole pies, pitchers, and friends. Expect a fun crowd, plenty of topping combos, and reliable late-night energy.
02
Deep-dish heavyweight
PizzaPapalis
Downtown Near The Ballpark • Chicago- And Detroit-Style Pizzeria • Best For Deep Dish And Detroit-Style
A downtown go-to when you want a serious, fork-and-knife deep dish or thick, crispy-edged pan pizza.
PizzaPapalis is where Toledoans head when a thin crust just won’t cut it. The deep-dish pies come out bubbling with cheese and toppings, with a buttery crust that holds up to the weight. It’s a sit-down spot worth planning for—call ahead or be ready to wait a bit while your pizza bakes to that classic, indulgent thickness.
03
Best campus-area hangout
Stubborn Brother Pizza Bar
Near University Of Toledo • Lively Pizza Bar With Big New York-Style Pies • Best For Groups And Game Days
A high-energy pizza bar turning out oversized pies, craft beer, and plenty of TV screens near campus.
Stubborn Brother leans into the pizza-bar hybrid, with big, shareable pies and a tap list that keeps things interesting. It’s a natural meeting spot for students, alumni, and neighborhood regulars, especially on game days. Go for the specialty pizzas, grab a table with a view of the TVs, and plan to stay for another slice.
04
Neighborhood standby
Hindsight Pizza
West Toledo Off Laskey Road • Takeout-Focused Neighborhood Pizzeria • Best For Carryout And Delivery
A dependable West Toledo shop known for well-topped pies, wings, and quick, friendly service.
Hindsight Pizza is the kind of place locals keep on speed dial for busy weeknights and casual weekends. The crust lands right in the sweet spot between chewy and crisp, with toppings that feel generous rather than sparse. Round out an order with wings or cheesy bread and you’ve got an easy, crowd-pleasing meal without leaving the neighborhood.
05
Wood-fired standout
ZaZa Wood-Fired Pizza
Sylvania Avenue Corridor • Cozy Wood-Fired Neapolitan-Style Spot • Best For Date Night And Shareable Pies
A warm, sit-down spot where blistered, wood-fired pies come out quickly and pair well with a glass of wine.
ZaZa specializes in thinner, airy crusts that pick up just enough char from the wood oven to stay light but flavorful. Toppings lean a little more modern here, with options beyond the usual pepperoni-and-mushroom routine. It’s a relaxed choice for a low-key date, but still casual enough for a small group looking to split a few different pies.