01
Best Ohio Valley classic
DiCarlo's Original Pizza
Downtown Toronto • Iconic Ohio Valley Square-Cut Shop • Go-To For Classic Trays
Crisp, square-cut pizza served on trays with a cult following among Toronto locals.
This downtown Toronto outpost of DiCarlo's serves the style of pizza many Ohio Valley natives grew up on. Expect a crunchy, airy crust, tangy sauce, and cheese and toppings finished on the pie as it comes out of the oven. It is a straightforward counter-service spot, but the flavor and nostalgia make it a must-try stop in town.
02
Best family-friendly spot
Iggy's Pizza & Pasta
North End Of Toronto • Family-Run Pizza And Pasta Joint • Best For Sit-Down Family Dinners
Hearty pizzas share the menu with crowd-pleasing pasta and wings in a relaxed local setting.
Iggy's offers a cozy, no-rush atmosphere where families linger over big pies and plates of pasta. The crust leans classic American, with plenty of cheese and toppings to satisfy varied tastes at the table. It is the kind of place where regulars are known by name and big orders for youth teams and gatherings are an everyday occurrence.
03
Best fast delivery
Domino's Pizza
Franklin Street Corridor • National Delivery Chain Outpost • Top Pick For Quick Delivery
Customizable pizzas and sides with reliably fast delivery across Toronto and nearby neighborhoods.
This Franklin Street Domino's is the workhorse option when you want pizza on the table without leaving the house. The online ordering and frequent deals make it especially handy for game nights, late study sessions, or last-minute group orders. While the menu is familiar, the team here is known for quick turnarounds and consistent execution.
04
Worth-the-drive legend
DiCarlo's Original Pizza – Steubenville
Steubenville Downtown Riverfront • Historic Ohio Valley Pizza Counter • Iconic Regional Experience
The flagship DiCarlo's shop where the region’s beloved tray pizza style draws fans from across the valley.
Just a short drive south in Steubenville, this original DiCarlo's location is a pilgrimage stop for pizza fans. The routine is simple: order a tray, wait at the busy counter, and dig into hot, crisp squares topped with cool cheese and pepperoni. If you want to understand why Ohio Valley pizza is such a big deal, this is the place to start.
05
Crowd-pleasing party pizza
Giannamore's Pizza
Wintersville Main Strip • Old-School Takeout Pizzeria • Best For Big Groups And Parties
Cheesy sheet pizzas and trays that are ideal for feeding a hungry crowd on a budget.
A few minutes west in Wintersville, Giannamore's is a go-to when you need to feed a lot of people fast. The pizzas come in generous rectangular pans with a soft, satisfying crust and plenty of cheese, making them perfect for parties, team dinners, and family gatherings. Call ahead on busy weekends, because locals know this is one of the area’s most reliable crowd-pleasers.