01
Best overall pick
Catanzaro's Pizza & Subs
Springfield - South Side • Classic Italian-American Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A long-running Springfield shop known for hearty, cheese-heavy pies and old-school subs that travel well back to Tremont City.
Catanzaro's leans into a familiar, comforting style: a slightly thicker crust, plenty of sauce, and a generous blanket of cheese that browns nicely at the edges. The classic pepperoni or deluxe with sausage, green pepper, and onion are crowd-pleasers when you’re feeding a mix of tastes. It’s a reliable go-to for carryout nights, with subs and sides that make it easy to round out a full family meal.
02
Best for big groups
Marion's Piazza
Springfield - Bechtle Avenue Corridor • Dayton-Style, Family-Friendly Pizza Hall • Best For Families And Teams
A sprawling, no-nonsense dining room built around thin, square-cut pizzas that are ideal for sharing with a crowd.
Marion's is a Dayton-area institution, and the Springfield location brings that same cracker-thin, party-cut pizza style close to Tremont City. Toppings are chopped fine and spread edge-to-edge, so every small square has a bit of everything. With plenty of seating, quick service, and a menu that keeps kids and grandparents happy, it’s the easy answer when you’re wrangling a team dinner or birthday outing.
03
Dayton-style classic
Cassano's Pizza King
Springfield - East Side • Thin-Crust, Party-Cut Pizzeria • Best For Shareable Pies
Iconic Dayton-style pizza with a light, crisp crust and finely chopped toppings, sliced into small squares made for grazing.
Cassano's has a loyal following for its distinctive dough and sweet-leaning red sauce, a combo that works especially well with classic pepperoni or sausage-and-mushroom. The pizzas are light enough that a group can try a couple of different topping combos without feeling overloaded. It’s a smart pick when you want something a bit different from standard chain pies but still familiar and unfussy.
04
Worth the drive to Urbana
Don's Pizza
Urbana - Downtown • Old-School Carryout Shop • Best Nostalgic Pick
A no-frills Urbana staple turning out crisp, square-cut pies with a hometown feel and loyal following.
Don's is the kind of small-town pizza joint that feels unchanged in the best possible way: modest storefront, friendly counter, and boxes going out the door steadily on weekend nights. The crust runs thin and slightly chewy, with a sauce that balances tang and a hint of sweetness. If you like a bit of char and edge-to-edge toppings, the works or pepperoni-and-bacon combo is worth the extra minutes’ drive from Tremont City.
05
Neighborhood slice stop
Bada Bing Pizzeria
Springfield - Near Downtown • Casual New York-Style Slice Shop • Best Quick Bite
A laid-back spot where you can grab a foldable slice or a whole pie before heading back up toward Tremont City.
Bada Bing focuses on big, wide slices with a foldable crust and a slightly chewy bite, the kind of pizza that’s easy to eat on the go. Toppings skew classic, but the kitchen isn’t shy about piling them on, so a simple cheese or pepperoni hits the spot. It’s especially handy when you’re in Springfield for errands or a game and want a fast, satisfying pizza fix without sitting down for a full restaurant meal.