01
Closest classic slice
Little Italy Pizza
Glouster • Small-Town Takeout Pizzeria • Closest Go-To From Trimble
A no-frills local favorite just up the road, known for generous toppings and friendly, small-town service.
Only a few minutes from Trimble, Little Italy Pizza is the classic call when you want something hot, cheesy, and familiar without driving to Athens. The crust is sturdy enough to handle plenty of toppings, and the sauce leans savory instead of sweet. It is the kind of place where they remember your usual and big game nights can mean a line of locals picking up family-size orders.
02
Best for families
Pizza Cottage
The Plains • Casual Dine-In And Carryout • Family-Friendly Choice
A roomy, family-oriented spot with a broad menu and consistent, crowd-pleasing pies.
Head to Pizza Cottage in The Plains when you need something that works for everyone at the table. The crust sits right between thin and thick, with plenty of topping combos plus salads, subs, and sides to round out a meal. It is a straightforward, comfortable choice for youth sports teams, birthday dinners, or an easy stop on the way back toward Trimble.
03
Most creative pies
Avalanche Pizza
Athens – East Side • Artisan Pizzeria And Slice Shop • Destination For Foodies
A creative Athens institution turning out loaded specialty pies, inventive slices, and plenty of options for adventurous eaters.
If you are willing to make the drive from Trimble, Avalanche Pizza is the spot to seek out when you want more than just pepperoni. Expect chewy, flavorful crusts and toppings that run from classic combos to funky specials packed with local ingredients. It is ideal when you are pairing pizza with a night in Athens or want to impress out-of-town visitors with something they cannot get from a chain.
04
Late-night classic
Goodfella's Pizza
Athens – Court Street • Counter-Service Slice Joint • Best For A Night Out
A Court Street staple serving big, foldable slices that hit the spot after a game, a show, or a late night in Athens.
Goodfella's is built around quick service and oversized slices, making it a natural stop when you are already in Athens and hunger hits. The menu leans toward classic toppings, but the real draw is grabbing a fresh, hot slice and eating it on the go. Locals know it as a reliable, no-fuss option that stays open later than most sit-down spots around Trimble.
05
Game-day hangout
Courtside Pizza
Athens – Near Court Street • Sports-Bar Style Pizzeria • Best For Groups And Pitchers
A relaxed Athens standby with big pies, cold drinks, and plenty of room to linger with a group.
Courtside Pizza feels made for catching up after a game or making a casual night of it with friends from around Trimble. The pizzas are straightforward and shareable, with lots of basket-style appetizers to fill the table. It is the spot to choose when you want to sit down, watch a game, and split a couple of large pies instead of just grabbing takeout.