01
Best overall pick
Main Street Pizzeria
Downtown Dresden • Small-Town Pizzeria With Classic Ohio-Style Pies • Best Overall Pick
A friendly Main Street shop turning out crowd-pleasing pizzas just a few minutes from Trinway.
This is the kind of place where the staff quickly learns your usual and the pizza comes out hot, cheesy, and reliably good. Crusts are sturdy enough for plenty of toppings, and the menu covers familiar favorites without getting fussy. It is an easy go-to for weeknight carryout or a low-key family dinner after a day around Dresden and Trinway.
02
Best for carryout
Creno's Pizza Dresden
South Dresden • Carryout-Focused Pizza Shop • Go-To For Takeout And Delivery
A longtime local option when you want a hot pizza run out for pickup or delivered to your door.
Creno's leans into hearty, topping-heavy pies that feel built for game nights and casual get-togethers. The square-cut slices and generous cheese make it easy to feed a crowd without overthinking the order. It is especially handy for Trinway households that want dependable delivery from just down the road in Dresden.
03
Classic sit-down choice
Adornetto's Selected Italian
Downtown Zanesville • Old-School Italian Restaurant And Pizzeria • Best For A Sit-Down Meal
A Zanesville institution where thin, saucy pizzas share the spotlight with classic Italian comfort dishes.
Adornetto's has a loyal following for its crisp-edged, square-cut pies and family-friendly dining room. It is the spot to choose when you want more of an evening out than a quick pickup, with red-sauce pasta, salads, and garlic bread backing up the pizza lineup. For Trinway residents, it is worth the short drive when you are celebrating or hosting out-of-town guests.
04
Hearty local favorite
Wally's Pizza
West Zanesville • Casual, Family-Run Pizza Joint • Top Pick For Big, Cheesy Pies
A no-frills shop known for substantial, cheese-heavy pizzas and generous portions.
Wally's feels like the classic neighborhood pizza place, with straightforward combinations piled onto soft, satisfying crusts. The pizzas are built to be filling, making them a smart choice when you are feeding a hungry group after a game or road trip. It is an easy swing from Trinway if you are already heading toward Zanesville on errands or for a night out.
05
Best for groups
Pizza Cottage Zanesville
North Zanesville • Lively Regional Pizza Chain Spot • Best For Groups And Game Nights
A bustling sit-down pizza stop with plenty of space, shareable pies, and a broad menu.
Pizza Cottage offers a mix of specialty pizzas, wings, and appetizers that works well when everyone at the table wants something different. The roomy dining area and upbeat atmosphere make it an easy choice for teams, large families, or friends meeting in the middle from around Muskingum County. For Trinway locals, it is a convenient option when you want pizza plus a bit of a buzz in the room.