01
Best overall pick
New York Pizzeria Restaurant
East Main Street, Trotwood • Classic New York-Style Pizzeria • Go-To Neighborhood Slice
Foldable New York-style slices and hearty pies make this long-running Main Street spot a staple for Trotwood pizza fans.
If you want a classic pizza joint feel without leaving Trotwood, New York Pizzeria Restaurant is the move. The crust lands in that sweet spot between chewy and crisp, with plenty of cheese and straightforward toppings that let the sauce shine. It is an easy choice for everything from a solo slice run to feeding a hungry crew on game night.
02
Best for carryout
Philly Pizza
Salem Avenue Corridor • Casual Takeout And Wings Spot • Best For Late-Night Cravings
Known for generous portions and bold flavors, Philly Pizza is a go-to when you want a hot box of pizza and wings to bring home.
Tucked along Salem Avenue, Philly Pizza leans into hearty, comfort-food pizza with plenty of cheese and toppings piled on thick. The menu usually stretches beyond pies into wings, subs, and other fast favorites, which makes it handy when everyone wants something a little different. Call ahead for carryout and you can be back on the couch before the next quarter starts.
03
Family-friendly chain
Pizza Hut
East Main Street Shopping Strip • National Pizza Chain With Dine-In And Delivery • Most Reliable Delivery
This Trotwood Pizza Hut is ideal when you want familiar pies, easy online ordering, and predictable delivery times.
When convenience tops the priority list, the Pizza Hut on East Main Street earns its spot. Pan pizzas, stuffed crust, and wings cover the basics, and regular deals make it budget-friendly for families. It is especially useful on busy weeknights when you want dinner to arrive at the door without any guesswork.
04
Worth the drive
Marion's Piazza
Englewood, Just North Of Trotwood • Dayton-Style Thin-Crust Institution • Classic Regional Icon
A Dayton-area legend, Marion's in Englewood serves ultra-thin, party-cut pies that many locals consider essential eating.
If you are up for a short drive, Marion's Piazza in Englewood is the closest taste of Dayton’s signature thin-crust style. Expect cracker-thin crust, edge-to-edge toppings, and those classic square party cuts that disappear fast at the table. The big, open dining room and old-school vibe make it a natural choice for team outings and family gatherings.
05
Best for sit-down night out
Dewey's Pizza
Near The University Of Dayton • Craft Pizza And Beer Restaurant • Best For Foodies And Craft Beer Fans
Dewey's pairs creative specialty pies with a solid draft list, making it a strong option for a more polished pizza night near Dayton.
When you want something beyond the usual pepperoni and cheese, Dewey's delivers with inventive topping combos and well-balanced flavors. Pies like goat cheese and roasted veggies or buffalo chicken feel a step up from standard takeout, and the rotating beer lineup suits lingering over a meal. It is a bit of a drive from Trotwood, but a good pick when you are already heading toward the city.