01
Classic Dayton-style institution
Marion's Piazza
Experiment Farm Road Corridor • Dayton-Style Thin-Crust Pizza Hall • Local Institution
A spacious, old-school spot for ultra-thin, square-cut pies and casual group gatherings.
Marion's brings the classic Dayton-style experience to Troy, with cracker-thin crust, edge-to-edge toppings, and pizzas cut into snackable squares. The big dining room is ideal for teams, birthday parties, or post-game meetups. Go heavy on the toppings and plan to share a couple of large pies with the table.
02
Best for craft pizza and beer
Old Scratch Pizza
Downtown Troy • Wood-Fired Neapolitan-Style Pizzeria And Taproom • Best For Craft Beer And Groups
Lively downtown spot known for blistered, wood-fired pies, inventive toppings, and a strong tap list.
Set in a converted historic space, Old Scratch feels like a modern beer hall with a serious pizza habit. Pies come out fast from the wood-fired ovens with chewy, leopard-spotted crusts and toppings that range from classic margherita to spicy, chef-y combos. It’s an easy choice when you want a sit-down meal with friends, a few pints, and something more adventurous than standard delivery pizza.
03
Cozy neighborhood pick
Matty Q's Pizza and Subs
South Market Street • Family-Owned Pizza And Subs Shop • Neighborhood Favorite
Casual, locally run spot turning out hearty pizzas and subs with a friendly, small-town vibe.
Matty Q's feels like the kind of place regulars put on speed dial, with consistently good pies and staff who remember your usual. The pizzas lean classic Midwestern: generous cheese, balanced sauce, and plenty of topping combinations, plus subs if someone in the group is pizza-ed out. It’s a dependable choice when you want something local, unfussy, and satisfying for a weeknight dinner.
04
Best for big orders
Donatos Pizza
West Main Street Retail Strip • Ohio-Style Thin-Crust Chain • Best For Shareable Party Orders
Edge-to-edge toppings on thin, crispy crusts make this an easy go-to for feeding a crowd.
Donatos is an Ohio original, and the Troy location delivers that signature thin crust loaded right out to the edges with toppings. The menu is built for groups, from party-cut pizzas to wings and salads that can cover a whole team or office. Order a mix of specialty pies and a big salad when you need something reliable for game night or a casual gathering.
05
Reliable takeout standby
Marco's Pizza
West Main Street Near I-75 • Carryout And Delivery-Focused Pizzeria • Best For Quick Takeout Night
Convenient spot for customizable pizzas, cheesy breads, and wings when you need dinner on the fly.
Located close to the interstate, Marco's is a handy option for both locals and travelers rolling through Troy. The menu hits all the familiar notes: build-your-own pies, hearty specialty pizzas, and plenty of sides to round out the order. It’s especially useful on busy nights when you want something hot, predictable, and ready for pickup or delivery without much planning.