01
Best overall pick
Zifer's Mary Pizza Shop
Downtown New Philadelphia • Old-School Hometown Pizzeria • Classic Local Favorite
A New Philadelphia staple turning out no-nonsense pies that taste like Friday night in a small town.
Zifer's Mary Pizza Shop is the kind of place where the crust is sturdy, the toppings are generous, and the staff probably knows your order by your second visit. The menu sticks to classic combinations, with pepperoni, sausage, and extra cheese leading the way. It is an easy go-to when you want familiar flavors, fair prices, and a relaxed, hometown feel after a short drive from Tuscarawas.
02
Best for big groups
Your Pizza Shop
East High Avenue, New Philadelphia • Classic Ohio Pizza Shop • Best For Shareable Pies
A long-running local chain location known for big, crowd-pleasing pizzas and plenty of sides.
Your Pizza Shop feels built for team parties, family gatherings, and game nights, thanks to its oversized pies and familiar, comfort-food style. The crust is on the thicker side, with a saucy, cheesy profile that satisfies everyone from kids to picky adults. Add in wings, subs, and salads and it becomes a one-stop order when you are feeding a carload from Tuscarawas.
03
Cozy neighborhood choice
Granato's Pizza
West New Philadelphia • Family-Run Italian Pizzeria • Relaxed Sit-Down Option
A warm, family-oriented spot where pizzas come with a side of small-town hospitality.
Granato's leans into a more Italian-restaurant feel, with pizzas that balance a flavorful sauce, plenty of cheese, and well-seasoned toppings. It is a comfortable place to sit down for a casual meal, especially if you like to pair your pie with a salad or a plate of pasta. From Tuscarawas, it makes a nice choice when you want to make pizza night feel a bit more like a proper dinner out.
04
Best pizza-and-a-beer stop
Dennison Yard
Historic Dennison Rail District • Casual Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria • Great For Lingering Dinners
A roomy, railroad-side restaurant where pizza shares the spotlight with hearty Italian and pub-style fare.
Dennison Yard is a favorite when you want pizza plus a wider menu and a cold drink in a lively, historic setting. The pizzas are well-topped and shareable, making them ideal alongside appetizers, pasta, or a burger for a mixed group. It is an easy recommendation from Tuscarawas when you are meeting friends and want more of an evening out than a quick carryout run.
05
Reliable takeout pick
Giovanni's Pizzeria
Uhrichsville • Neighborhood Pizza And Pasta Joint • Best For Takeout And Delivery
A straightforward, no-frills shop turning out hot, hearty pizzas that travel well back to Tuscarawas.
Giovanni's focuses on the essentials: well-baked crusts, plenty of cheese, and a lineup of toppings that feels tailor-made for weeknight takeout. The menu usually includes stromboli, pasta, and sandwiches, so everyone in the house can find something. If you are in Tuscarawas and want to grab a pizza on the way home without making a full night of it, this is a convenient, dependable choice.