01
Best overall pick
Zifaro's Pizza
North Water Street, Uhrichsville • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A long-running Uhrichsville staple turning out hearty, no-nonsense pies that locals swear by.
Zifaro's feels like the kind of pizzeria every small town wishes it had: straightforward, friendly, and focused on making satisfying pizza. The crust has enough chew to stand up to generous toppings, and the cheese coverage is reliably ample. It is an easy first choice when you want a carryout pizza that tastes like it came from a neighborhood institution rather than a chain.
02
Most reliable delivery
Domino's Pizza
Water Street Corridor, Uhrichsville • Delivery-Focused Chain Shop • Late-Night Delivery Pick
Fast, predictable Domino's pies with all the familiar crust styles and sauces, right in town.
When convenience matters as much as the slice, the Uhrichsville Domino's is the dependable option that answers the call. You get the full national menu, from hand-tossed and pan pizzas to specialty combinations and crowd-pleasing sides. It is especially handy for late evenings, last-minute team dinners, or nights when you want to track your pizza from oven to doorstep.
03
Best for game nights
Papa Johns Pizza
North Uhrichsville • Carryout And Delivery Chain • Best For Group Orders
Classic Papa Johns pies with their trademark crust and garlic sauce, ideal for feeding a hungry crew.
Papa Johns in Uhrichsville is a go-to when you are ordering for a group and want familiar flavors everyone recognizes. Large specialty pizzas, wings, and breadsticks make it easy to cover all the bases for a game night or family gathering. The crust leans soft and bready, and the included garlic sauce is practically required for dipping slices and crusts alike.
04
Old-school favorite
Pangrazio's Pizza & Spaghetti House
Downtown Dennison • Family Italian Restaurant And Pizzeria • Best For Hearty Sit-Down Meals
A short drive from Uhrichsville, this family Italian spot serves classic pies alongside big plates of pasta.
Pangrazio's in nearby Dennison has the feel of a hometown Italian dining room, where pizza shares the spotlight with hearty spaghetti and other red-sauce comforts. The pizzas come out generously topped, with a sauce that leans savory and slightly sweet, making them easy crowd-pleasers. It is a smart pick when you want a proper sit-down meal but still crave a couple of pizzas for the table.
05
Best hangout spot
Dennison Yard
Near The Dennison Railroad Depot • Railroad-Themed Bar And Pizza Spot • Best For Casual Groups
Laid-back tavern atmosphere with pizza, pub fare, and a local crowd just minutes from Uhrichsville.
Set by the historic rail yard in Dennison, Dennison Yard offers a relaxed place to linger over pizza and a drink. The pies lean comforting and shareable, with topping combos that suit both traditionalists and less fussy eaters. It is the kind of spot where you can bring friends, split a couple of pizzas, and soak up a little local character along with your slice.