01
Best overall pick
Benny's Pizza
Marysville - West End • Lively Pizza Tavern With Big Patio • Local Legend
Big pies, a sprawling patio, and live music make Benny's the go-to pizza spot for many Union County locals.
Benny's is the place people in and around Unionville Center name first when you ask where to grab pizza. The crust lands in that sweet spot between chewy and crisp, toppings are generous, and the menu covers everything from classic pepperoni to loaded specialty pies. On warm evenings, the outdoor space and occasional live music turn a simple pizza night into an easygoing outing.
02
Best for watching the game
Boston's Pizza Restaurant & Sports Bar
Marysville - Coleman's Crossing Area • Sports Bar And Full-Service Pizzeria • Best For Game Day
If you want serious screen coverage with your pizza, Boston's delivers cold drinks, plenty of TVs, and a wide-ranging menu.
Boston's balances a sizable pizza lineup with all the sports-bar staples, so it works just as well for a casual family dinner as it does for a big game. Flatbreads and specialty pizzas lean toward bold, layered flavors, and there are plenty of wings and appetizers if your group is grazing. It’s an easy pick when you need something everyone can agree on and don’t mind a little buzz in the room.
03
Best value for families
Buckeye Family Pizzeria
Marysville - East Side • Casual Family-Run Pizzeria • Best For Families
Straightforward, well-priced pies and a friendly staff make Buckeye Family Pizzeria a low-fuss favorite for takeout or dine-in.
Buckeye Family Pizzeria leans into the basics and does them well: sturdy crust, plenty of cheese, and classic topping combinations that arrive hot and fast. It’s the kind of place where staff remember regulars and kids get excited about pizza night. Portion sizes are generous for the price, so it’s especially handy when you’re feeding a crowd from Unionville Center or nearby back roads.
04
Best thin-crust chain option
Donatos Pizza
Marysville - Near Shopping Corridor • Fast-Casual Ohio Chain Pizzeria • Reliable Weeknight Option
Donatos is the go-to for crisp, edge-to-edge topping coverage when you need pizza fast on the way to or from Marysville errands.
This Marysville outpost of the Ohio-born chain is especially convenient for Unionville Center residents combining pizza pickup with a grocery run or kids’ activities. The signature extra-thin crust and generous toppings stay consistent, so you know exactly what you’re getting. It’s a practical choice for weeknights when you want good pizza without lingering over a full restaurant experience.
05
Worth-the-drive classic
Jan & Tony's Pizza
Plain City • Old-School Small-Town Pizzeria • Worth The Drive
A Plain City standby, Jan & Tony's serves nostalgic, no-frills pizza that feels like a step back into a classic neighborhood shop.
Jan & Tony's has been quietly drawing pizza fans from Unionville Center and surrounding country roads for years. The vibe is simple and unpretentious, with pizzas that lean on a slightly thicker, comforting crust and traditional toppings. It’s the kind of small-town spot where a laid-back dine-in meal feels just right after a Saturday of errands or a local ballgame.