01
Classic Grove City tavern pie
Plank's On Broadway
Historic Downtown Grove City • Old‑School Tavern And Pizza Joint • Best Overall Pick
A lively Broadway staple known for its generously topped, slightly sweet‑sauce pizzas and neighborhood bar vibe.
Just a few minutes south of Urbancrest on Broadway, Plank's is the kind of place locals recommend first when you ask about Grove City pizza. The crust is sturdy but not too thick, with plenty of cheese and a sauce that leans just a touch sweet in true central Ohio style. Go for a classic pepperoni or build your own, then linger over a drink and people‑watch in the busy dining room.
02
NY‑influenced neighborhood slice
Grandstand Pizza Shop
Broadway Corridor, Grove City • Casual New York‑Style Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A cozy shop on Broadway turning out foldable New York‑style pies with plenty of game‑day energy.
Grandstand sits right on Broadway, making it an easy hop from Urbancrest for a quick pie or a laid‑back dinner. The pizza leans New York‑inspired: thinner crust, big slices, and toppings that run from straightforward pepperoni to hearty meat combinations. It’s a dependable choice before a local game, after a night out on Broadway, or when you just want a classic cheese pie done right.
03
Homey central‑Ohio style
Tammy's Pizza
Grove City Town Center Area • Family‑Run Carryout And Dine‑In Spot • Best For Families
A friendly, family‑oriented shop serving thick‑topped, central‑Ohio style pizzas and crowd‑pleasing sides.
Tammy's feels like the neighborhood pizza place everyone grew up with: plenty of booths, big pies, and staff who remember your usual order. The crust is classic Columbus‑area thin‑to‑medium, cut into squares and loaded with toppings. It’s a particularly easy pick for families coming from Urbancrest, with shareable specialty pies, subs, and enough menu variety to keep everyone at the table happy.
04
Old‑school carryout legend
Zamarelli's Pizza Palace
North Grove City, Near Hoover Road • No‑Frills Carryout Pizzeria • Takeout Go‑To
A long‑running Grove City institution turning out thin, square‑cut pies that travel well back to Urbancrest.
Zamarelli's is a straightforward carryout shop that has built a loyal following on consistency and nostalgia. Expect a classic Columbus‑style thin crust, edge‑to‑edge toppings, and pizzas cut into tidy squares that work perfectly for sharing. It’s ideal when you want to swing by on the way home, grab a couple of large pies, and feed a crowd without fuss.
05
Game‑day pizza and wings
Massey's Pizza Sports Bar & Wing Pub
Grove City, Near Stringtown Road • Lively Sports‑Bar Pizzeria • Best For Watching The Game
A southwest‑side outpost of a central Ohio chain, pairing crispy‑edge pizzas with big screens and a full wing menu.
Just east of Urbancrest off Stringtown Road, Massey's offers a louder, more energetic take on the pizza night out. The pies come with a crisp crust and plenty of pepperoni curl, backed up by a long list of wings and bar snacks. It’s the spot to choose when you want to catch a Buckeyes or Crew game, split a couple of large pizzas, and make an evening of it with friends.