Utica may be a small village, but its pizza options punch above their weight, with longtime locals and newer shops sharing the spotlight. Within a short drive you can add a couple of Newark standouts to the mix, giving you everything from classic Ohio thin-crust to hearty, topping-loaded pies. Use this guide to decide where to grab your next slice, whether you are cruising through town or settling in for a laid-back night with friends.
A cozy Main Street staple turning out crowd-pleasing pies and subs with a classic small-town feel.
Locals lean on Nick's when they want familiar, well-topped pizzas without leaving the village. The menu sticks to the hits, from pepperoni and sausage to loaded specialty pies and oven-baked subs. It is an easy choice if you want a sit-down bite right in the middle of town.
Utica's made-daily dough specialist, known for generous cheese and reliable carryout dinners.
The Pizza Factory builds its pies on dough made fresh each day, which gives even simple topping combos a little extra lift. Expect a straightforward, family-friendly menu with plenty of classic and specialty pizzas plus the sides you would want for a movie night. Call ahead on busy evenings; the parking lot fills quickly when local teams are playing.
A North Utica go-to for thick, cheesy pizzas piled high and packed neatly for takeout.
Stone Brother's leans into hearty, topping-loaded pies that travel well, making it a favorite for takeout or delivery-style dining at home. The crust runs on the thicker side, with plenty of cheese and sauce to stand up to extra toppings. It is the spot many locals choose when they are feeding a crowd for game night or a backyard get-together.
Classic Ohio-style thin-crust pies cut in squares, ideal when you are sharing with a big group.
About a 20-minute drive from Utica, Donatos in Newark gives you the chain's signature edge-to-edge toppings on a crisp, square-cut crust. The dining room is casual and family-friendly, but it is just as common for people to grab large orders for parties and team dinners. If you like your pepperoni crunchy at the edges and every slice covered, this is the style for you.
Lively sit-down pizzeria with big, shareable pies and plenty of room for families or groups.
Pizza Cottage brings a more dine-in feel, with roomy booths, TVs, and a menu built around substantial pizzas, wings, and salads. The crust lands between thin and thick, giving a little chew without feeling heavy, and there are enough topping combinations to keep regulars interested. It is a smart stop if you are already in Newark and want a relaxed meal before heading back toward Utica.