01
Best overall pick
Samosky's Homestyle Pizzeria
Valley City Center • Family-Friendly Dine-In Pizzeria • Local Institution
Award-winning, generously topped pies and a big covered patio make Samosky's the classic Valley City pizza night destination.
Samosky's is the spot locals name first, thanks to its loaded specialty pizzas, homestyle crust, and cozy dining room that feels like a community hangout. On warm evenings, the covered patio fills up with families and teams celebrating after a game. It’s the place to linger over a extra-saucy pie, a cold drink, and plenty of small-town atmosphere.
02
Best takeout choice
Valley Pizza Co.
Valley City Outskirts • Carryout And Delivery Shop • Weeknight Standby
Straightforward, well-made pies and dependable delivery make Valley Pizza Co. a go-to when you just want good pizza without any fuss.
Valley Pizza Co. leans into the basics: sturdy crust, plenty of cheese, and toppings that are piled on instead of sprinkled. The menu sticks to crowd-pleasers, with specialty combinations that feel familiar rather than fussy. It’s the kind of place people keep on speed dial for busy weeknights, last-minute get-togethers, and low-key Friday dinners at home.
03
Most creative slices
Ohio Pie Co. (Brunswick)
Brunswick - Pearl Road • Trendy Craft-Pizza Shop • Destination For Pizza Fans
Ultra-crisp, square-cut Ohio-style pies and rotating, offbeat toppings make Ohio Pie Co. worth the quick drive from Valley City.
Ohio Pie Co. has built a cult following around its thin, crispy, edge-to-edge pizzas cut into squares and loaded with inventive flavors. Expect playful topping combinations, seasonal specials, and a fun, slightly loud shop that feels more like a craft beer bar than a traditional pizzeria. It’s the pick when you’re in the mood to try something new and don’t mind a quick hop over to Brunswick.
04
Best pizza-and-chicken combo
Gionino's Pizzeria (Brunswick)
Brunswick - Grafton Road • Casual Counter-Serve Pizzeria • Game-Day Go-To
Thickly topped pies and the famous fried chicken bucket make this Gionino’s a staple for parties and game days near Valley City.
Gionino’s in Brunswick is the move when you’re feeding a crowd that wants more than just pizza. Their pies are hearty, with chewy crusts and serious cheese pull, but the crispy fried chicken is what often seals the deal for big orders. Call ahead on weekends or during big games—locals know this is the place to cover the coffee table in boxes and dig in.
05
Most reliable chain pick
Master Pizza (Medina)
Medina - North Court Street • Modern Carryout-Focused Pizzeria • Crowd-Pleasing Choice
Consistent, competition-influenced pies and a broad topping list make Master Pizza in Medina a safe bet for mixed tastes.
Master Pizza brings a polished, regional-chain feel, but the dough and sauce are closer to what you’d expect from an independent shop. The build-your-own options are extensive, and their specialty pizzas skew toward bold flavors without getting too weird for traditionalists. It’s a smart pick when you’re ordering for a group with different tastes and want something everyone will be happy with.