01
Best overall pick
Six Hundred Downtown
Downtown Bellefontaine • Wood-Fired Neapolitan Pizzeria • Destination-Worthy Local Favorite
An award-winning, brick-oven shop that’s worth planning your Valley Hi trip around.
Six Hundred Downtown is the place locals point to when they want to impress out-of-town friends with just how good small-town pizza can be. Hand-stretched dough, blistered crusts, and classic toppings done right make it a clear standout. Go early on busy nights or be ready to wait—this is the kind of spot people build an evening around.
02
Best for game night
Donatos Pizza
East Bellefontaine • Crispy Thin-Crust Chain Pizzeria • Go-To For Big Groups
A reliable thin-crust favorite with edge-to-edge toppings and easy online ordering.
When you’ve got a cabin full of skiers or a family gathering in Valley Hi, Donatos is the move for feeding a crowd fast. The signature thin crust holds up under generous toppings, and the menu covers everything from classic pepperoni to veggie-heavy combinations. It’s an especially handy option if you want predictable quality and efficient pickup or delivery.
03
Best old-school flavor
Cassano's Pizza King
South Main Street, Bellefontaine • Dayton-Style Square-Cut Pizzeria • Nostalgic Regional Classic
A regional chain with a loyal following for its cracker-thin crust and square-cut pies.
Cassano’s brings that distinctly Ohio, square-cut style that plenty of Logan County families grew up on. The crust is thin and crisp, the sauce leans tangy, and the toppings are chopped finely enough that every bite feels balanced. It’s a smart stop if you’re curious about classic regional pizza beyond the national chains.
04
Best late-night option
Domino’s Pizza
North Bellefontaine • National Delivery Pizzeria • Late-Night And Convenience Pick
Fast, customizable pizza that shines when you want something hot after a long drive or ski session.
Domino’s in Bellefontaine is all about speed and consistency, which hits the spot when you’re rolling back to Valley Hi after a long day. With multiple crust styles, sauces, and toppings, it’s easy to keep everyone in the group happy. The tracking app and reliable delivery make it a dependable fallback when other kitchens have gone dark for the night.
05
Best for classic pan pizza
Pizza Hut
West Bellefontaine • Casual Dine-In And Carryout Pizzeria • Comfort-Food Favorite
Familiar pan and stuffed-crust pizzas served in a laid-back, family-friendly setting.
If your idea of pizza comfort is a buttery pan crust and a booth by the window, the Bellefontaine Pizza Hut will feel just right. It’s an easy choice for families staying near Valley Hi who want a sit-down meal without overthinking it. Pair a couple of pies with breadsticks and salad, and you’ve got a simple, satisfying post-slope dinner.