01
Best overall pick
Josie's Pizza West
Hilltop / West Broad • Old-School Columbus-Style Pizzeria • Local Favorite For Dine-In And Carryout
A classic west side bar-and-pizza combo with thin, crispy pies and a loyal neighborhood following.
If you want the full west side pizza experience, Josie’s is where you start. Expect cracker-thin, square-cut Columbus-style pies loaded edge-to-edge with toppings, cold beer, and a laid-back barroom feel. It’s the kind of place where regulars know the staff, game days get loud, and leftovers rarely make it to the next morning.
02
Delivery standby
Donatos Pizza – West Broad Street
West Broad Corridor • Local Chain Takeout And Delivery Shop • Most Reliable Delivery Option
Edge-to-edge toppings and consistently fast delivery make this Donatos a go-to for Valleyview weeknights.
Born in Columbus, Donatos is the default choice for many west siders when nobody feels like cooking. The West Broad location is close enough to Valleyview that pizzas usually arrive hot and on time, whether you’re feeding a couple of people or a houseful. Thin crust, predictable quality, and plenty of topping combos keep it in steady rotation.
03
Neighborhood institution
Minelli's Pizza & Pasta
Lincoln Village • Family-Run Italian Joint • Best For Sit-Down Family Dinners
A long-running west side staple where the pizza shares the spotlight with big plates of red-sauce comfort food.
Minelli’s has been serving the west side for decades, and it shows in the well-worn booths and steady stream of regulars. The pizza leans hearty, with generous cheese and toppings, but you can round out the table with pasta, garlic bread, and salads. It’s an easy choice when you want a proper sit-down meal that still revolves around pizza.
04
Game-day favorite
Flyers Pizza & Subs – West Broad
Galloway / West Side • Casual Pizza And Subs Shop • Best For Big Groups And Takeout
Thick, cheesy pizzas and crowd-pleasing subs make Flyers a strong pick for parties, game days, and hungry families.
Flyers is built for feeding a crowd: big pies, hefty subs, and shareable sides like wings and wedges. The West Broad shop is a quick drive from Valleyview and handles large orders without much fuss, which is handy for parties or office lunches. The crust runs a bit thicker here, so it’s especially good if you like a more filling slice.
05
Late-night slice spot
Mikey's Late Night Slice – Franklinton
Franklinton Arts District • Funky Urban Slice Shop • Best For Late-Night And Pre-Show Bites
Oversized slices, quirky specials, and a lively patio scene make this Franklinton outpost worth the short drive from Valleyview.
When you want something a little more downtown without dealing with the Short North, the Franklinton Late Night Slice hits the sweet spot. Grab big New York–style slices, rotating specialty pies, and their signature garlicy dipping sauce before or after a show nearby. It’s casual, loud in a fun way, and ideal for a spontaneous night out.