01
Best overall pick
Dragon's Lair Pizza Pub
Van Buren Village Center • Small-Town Pizza Pub • Local Favorite
A laid‑back Main Street pub turning out generous, crowd‑pleasing pizzas right in the heart of Van Buren.
Dragon's Lair feels like the village living room, with friendly service, cold drinks, and pizzas built for sharing after a day at the park or ballfields. The crust is sturdy enough for plenty of toppings, and the menu branches out into subs and bar‑style snacks so everyone at the table can find something they like. It’s the obvious first stop if you want to stay close to Van Buren without sacrificing flavor.
02
Best for big groups
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill
West Findlay Near I-75 • Family-Friendly Pizza & Grill • Best For Groups And Sports
Lively and spacious, Beer Barrel pairs hefty pizzas with a full grill menu and plenty of screens for game day.
Just a short drive down I‑75, Beer Barrel is a natural choice when you’ve got a big crew and varied tastes to feed. Pizzas come in multiple sizes with a thick, chewy crust and lots of topping combinations, from straightforward pepperoni to pile‑on specialty pies. With burgers, wings, and a solid draft list, it’s as much a hangout spot as a place to grab dinner on the west side of Findlay.
03
Old-school classic
Jac & Do's Pizza
North Main, Findlay • Classic Ohio-Style Pizzeria • Best Nostalgic Slice
A long‑running local chain known for its thin, edge‑to‑edge toppings and no‑nonsense, hometown feel.
Jac & Do's is the kind of place locals grow up on, with pizza that leans toward Ohio tavern‑style: plenty of toppings, a crust that’s crisp at the edges, and square‑cut slices made for sharing. The atmosphere is simple and unpretentious, more about families and regulars than trends. It’s a dependable stop when you want a familiar pie that tastes like Friday night in northwest Ohio.
04
Delivery standout
AJ's Heavenly Pizza
East Side Of Findlay • Delivery-Focused Pizzeria • Best For Delivery And Carryout
A go‑to for delivery and carryout, with hearty, saucy pies that travel well back to Van Buren.
AJ's leans into the comfort‑food side of pizza, with substantial crusts, plenty of cheese, and a slightly sweet sauce that wins over kids and adults alike. The menu is built for easy ordering, whether you’re grabbing a couple of larges for a family night or mixing in breadsticks and salads. If you’d rather stay in your campsite or living room, this is one of the most reliable options to bring dinner to you.
05
Neighborhood favorite
Dougie John's Pizza
Near Downtown Findlay • Casual Neighborhood Spot • Quick Takeout Pick
A small, no‑frills shop turning out flavorful, affordable pies ideal for quick pickup on the way back to Van Buren.
Dougie John's keeps things straightforward: friendly staff, efficient service, and pizza that focuses on a well‑seasoned sauce and balanced toppings. The shop’s modest size and easy parking make it an easy add‑on to a downtown errand run or a post‑game pickup. When you want something tasty without turning dinner into an outing, this little spot quietly delivers.