01
Best small-town slice
The Pizza Dock
Downtown Brookville • Cozy Small-Town Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A classic Brookville mainstay turning out hefty, crowd-pleasing pies in a laid-back setting.
The Pizza Dock feels exactly like the kind of small-town pizzeria you hope to find a few minutes from Verona. The crust is sturdy enough to hold generous toppings, and the specialty combinations are clearly built with hungry locals in mind. Grab a booth with friends, or call ahead and pick up a couple of larges on your way back through town.
02
Top takeout option
Sarah's Pizza
Brookville, Near I-70 • Carry-Out Focused Neighborhood Shop • Quick Takeout Pick
Reliable, well-topped pies that make an easy stop right off the interstate.
Sarah's Pizza in Brookville is the go-to for anyone commuting past Verona who wants dinner sorted in one quick stop. The menu leans into classic Midwest comfort: thick layers of cheese, familiar toppings, and hearty specialty pizzas that feed a crowd. It is especially handy on busy weeknights when you want something hot and filling without a sit-down meal.
03
Best for families
Sarah's Pizza
New Lebanon, South Of Verona • Casual Family Pizzeria • Best For Families
A friendly New Lebanon outpost where pizza night easily turns into a full family outing.
The New Lebanon location of Sarah's Pizza is a comfortable choice when you are willing to drive a bit farther for a sit-down meal. Service is unhurried and friendly, and the menu covers everything from simple pepperoni to loaded deluxe pies and subs, so everyone at the table finds something they like. It is an easy pick for team celebrations or multigenerational family dinners.
04
Iconic Dayton-style pick
Marion's Piazza
Englewood, At The I-70 Corridor • Classic Dayton-Style Pizza Hall • Iconic Dayton-Style Choice
A big, bustling spot serving ultra-thin, square-cut pizzas piled edge-to-edge with toppings.
Marion's Piazza in Englewood is the closest taste of a true Dayton institution for Verona-area pizza fans. The crust is thin and crisp, the slices are cut into small squares, and the toppings come scattered all the way to the edge for maximum coverage. With its spacious dining room and fast-moving counter service, it works just as well for a quick bite as for a big group gathering.
05
Game-night standby
Cassano's Pizza King
Englewood, National Road Strip • Retro Thin-Crust Chain Outpost • Laid-Back Game-Night Spot
Old-school, cracker-thin pies with a loyal following and plenty of carry-out momentum.
Cassano's Pizza King brings another beloved take on Dayton-style thin crust to Englewood, within easy reach of Verona. Expect a crisp base, tangy sauce, and a nostalgic feel that pairs perfectly with a box of breadsticks and a ballgame on TV at home. It is an especially good move when you want something familiar and fast for a group that is not picky about toppings, as long as there is lots of cheese.