01
Best overall pick
Napoli's
Along Oh-339 In Vincent • Family-Run Italian Pizzeria • Local Favorite
Vincent’s own Napoli’s is the go-to spot when you want a classic, well-topped pie without leaving town.
Napoli’s feels like the definition of a small-town pizza staple: friendly staff, generous cheese, and crust that holds up under plenty of toppings. The menu leans toward familiar favorites, from pepperoni and sausage to hearty specialty pies and calzones. It’s an easy choice for a weeknight takeout order or a relaxed family dinner close to home.
02
Best for family takeout
Smitty's Pizza (Barlow/Vincent)
Barlow–Vincent Area On Oh-339 • Casual Carryout Pizza Joint • Best For Families
Smitty’s serves up big, crowd-pleasing pizzas that make it easy to feed a hungry family after work or ball games.
Tucked along OH‑339, Smitty’s is the kind of no-frills pizza place people grow up with and never stop ordering from. The crust is soft and slightly chewy, with plenty of sauce and cheese, and toppings are stacked on with a generous hand. Call ahead, swing by the counter, and you’ll be back on the road to Vincent with hot boxes in the back seat in no time.
03
Best Marietta outing
The Original Pizza Place
Downtown Marietta • Classic Mid-Ohio Valley Pizza Parlor • Destination Slice Shop
A short drive into downtown Marietta gets you to The Original Pizza Place, known for its thin, foldable slices and old-school vibe.
If you’re making an evening of it in Marietta, grabbing a pie or a few slices here is almost a ritual. The pizza leans New York–style, with a crisp but pliable crust, a straightforward tomato sauce, and just the right amount of cheese for folding and walking. It’s ideal before a stroll along the riverfront or as a quick stop with friends between errands in town.
04
Best small-town detour
Jukebox Pizza
Waterford Village • Small-Town Pizza And Subs Shop • Worth-The-Drive Pick
Jukebox Pizza in Waterford is a cozy, old-school stop where thick, cheesy pies feel made for sharing.
Locals don’t mind the country roads to Waterford when it means Jukebox Pizza for dinner. Expect hearty, slightly thicker crusts, gooey cheese, and classic topping combos that hit the spot after a long day. It has that community-hangout feel, so it works just as well for a relaxed dine-in meal as it does for taking a couple of loaded pizzas back home toward Vincent.
05
Best for late-night delivery
Domino's Pizza
Marietta College District • National Delivery Chain Pizzeria • Late-Night Pick
When it’s late, you’re tired, and you just want reliable pizza brought to your door, Marietta’s Domino’s is the practical choice.
While it’s a big-name chain, this Domino’s is popular with students and locals alike for its consistent pies and fast delivery across the Marietta–Vincent corridor. The menu is broad enough that everyone can find something, from customizable pizzas to wings, pasta, and cheesy bread. It’s the spot you turn to when cooking isn’t happening and you need an easy, predictable option that shows up hot.