Waldo • best pizza

5 Best Pizzerias & Pizza Places for Waldo Ohio

Waldo might be a small village, but you do not have to go far for a satisfying pizza night. Most locals point their cars toward nearby Marion, where long-running pizzerias sit alongside casual Italian spots. From overloaded party pies to crisp, sauce-forward slices, these are the places people around Waldo actually recommend. Expect unfussy rooms, plenty of cheese, and staff who remember regulars by name.

View List Contact Us

01 Best overall pick

Tubby's Pizza

Marion's South Side • Classic Hometown Pizzeria • Local Favorite

Old-school Marion staple turning out generously topped pies with a loyal local following.

Tubby’s is the kind of place where the pizza comes loaded, the booths are comfortable, and the staff seems to know everyone who walks in. The crust strikes a happy middle ground between soft and crisp, with plenty of cheese and sauce that leans just a bit sweet. It is a go-to for everything from casual date nights to picking up a couple of larges on the way back to Waldo.

02 Best dine-in choice

Sansotta's Fresh Italian

Near Downtown Marion • Casual Italian Restaurant With Pizza • Best For Sit-Down Meals

Comfortable Italian spot where you can linger over pizza, pasta, and a glass of wine.

Sansotta’s is ideal when you want pizza but also a proper sit-down dinner. The pies share the menu with pastas, salads, and Italian comfort dishes, so everyone in the group can find something. Think crisp-edged crusts, thoughtful toppings, and a relaxed dining room that feels more like a neighborhood trattoria than a typical slice shop.

03 Best family spot

Payne's Pizza & More

Marion's West Side • Family-Friendly Pizza And Subs Shop • Best For Families

Laid-back spot known for shareable pizzas, subs, and kid-friendly portions.

Payne’s leans into the “& More,” pairing hearty pizzas with wings, subs, and plenty of sides, which makes it easy to feed a mixed crowd. The dough is soft and chewy, with edge-to-edge cheese and toppings that do not feel skimpy. It is an easy choice for family nights when you are driving up from Waldo and need something everyone will happily split.

04 Best quick stop

Marco's Pizza

Marion's East Side • Takeout-Focused Chain Pizzeria • Quick Takeout Pick

Reliable chain option with customizable pies and fast turnaround for carryout or delivery.

Marco’s in Marion is popular with locals who want predictable, hot pizza without much planning. The menu covers classic builds, specialty pies, and a mix of cheesy breads and wings, so you can round out a full game-night spread. It is especially handy when you are staying near Waldo and want something you can grab on the way back down US-23.

05 Best for big orders

Donatos Pizza

Commercial Strip North Of Marion • Thin-Crust Ohio Chain Pizzeria • Game-Night Crowd Pleaser

Crisp, edge-to-edge thin crust pizzas that are great for feeding a hungry group.

Donatos is known for its signature thin crust and the way it pushes toppings all the way to the edge. The Marion location turns that into an advantage when you are ordering multiple larges for a crowd, since the squares are easy to share and stay crisp. It is a smart move for parties, office lunches, or any night when you are hosting friends from around Waldo.