01
Best overall pick
Ellie's Pizzeria
Walnut Creek Village • Cozy Small-Town Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A friendly village hangout turning out well-balanced pies and welcoming service right in Walnut Creek.
Ellie’s feels like the classic small-town pizzeria locals actually use, with plenty of familiar toppings and a few fun specialty combinations. It’s an easy walk from many inns and shops, so you can grab a pie after a day of browsing Walnut Creek’s boutiques. Expect a relaxed pace, generous portions, and a laid-back dining room that works for couples, families, and small groups alike.
02
Worth the drive
Park Street Pizza
Downtown Sugarcreek • Lively Farm-To-Table Pizzeria • Destination For Foodies
A short drive from Walnut Creek, this busy spot is known for fresh toppings, creative pies, and a small-town buzz.
Park Street Pizza leans hard into quality ingredients, with toppings that feel more farmers’ market than freezer case. The roomy dining area and steady carryout business make it a go-to for both sit-down meals and takeout back to your cabin or B&B. If you like trying specialty pies, this is where to branch out beyond basic pepperoni.
03
Brick-oven standout
Table Rock Brick Oven Pizza
Berlin Main Strip • Brick-Oven New York-Style Shop • Best For Crisp Crust Lovers
Brick-fired pies with a thin, lightly charred crust just off Berlin’s main tourist strip.
Table Rock is the place to go when you want a more defined, brick-oven bake and a crust with some chew and char. It’s an easy stop while you’re already in Berlin for shopping, and the menu balances classic combinations with a few bolder options. Pair a pie with a salad and settle in, or grab a box to enjoy on a nearby porch or patio.
04
Group-friendly choice
East of Chicago Pizza (Berlin)
East Berlin Corridor • Family-Friendly Pizza Chain • Best For Big Groups
A reliable spot offering pan, thin, and loaded specialty pies with plenty of space for families and groups.
The Berlin location of East of Chicago hits that sweet spot when you need something everyone will agree on, from kids to grandparents. You can choose your crust style, pile on toppings, and feed a crowd without much planning. It’s especially handy for larger gatherings, youth groups, or sports teams staying near Walnut Creek and Berlin.
05
Takeout staple
Fox's Pizza Den
Historic Millersburg • Classic Small-Town Pizza Parlor • Solid Takeout Option
A straightforward spot in Millersburg turning out hearty pies, subs, and wings that travel well.
Fox’s Pizza Den is a dependable choice when you’re headed back through Millersburg and want dinner ready by the time you reach your lodging. The pizzas are generously topped, and the menu’s subs and sides make it easy to round out a casual spread. Call ahead for carryout, swing through town, and you’re back on the road to Walnut Creek in minutes.