01
Top downtown classic
Sunrise Inn of Warren
Downtown Warren • Classic Tavern-Style Pizzeria And Restaurant • Old-School Local Institution
A Warren landmark pairing thick, cheesy Old World pizzas with a full menu and a hometown bar atmosphere.
Sunrise Inn is the spot locals name first when you ask where to get pizza downtown. The Old World pies come loaded with cheese and toppings, and the crust strikes a satisfying balance between soft and crisp. With garlic chicken, wings, and a full bar, it works just as well for a family dinner as it does for catching a game with friends.
02
Best overall pick
Red Plum Pizza & Pasta
Southeast Warren Corridor • Family-Run Pizza And Pasta Shop • Go-To For Balanced Crust And Toppings
Red Plum turns out reliably great pies with a well-seasoned sauce, generous toppings, and a neighborhood feel.
Red Plum is the kind of place where the staff remembers regulars and the pizza tastes like someone still cares about every step. The crust has enough chew to hold up under hearty toppings, and the sauce leans flavorful rather than overly sweet. Add in solid pasta dinners and salads and it becomes an easy weeknight standby or game-day carryout choice.
03
Coziest sit-down option
Salvatore's Italian Grill
Howland Area, Just East Of Warren • Full-Service Italian Restaurant With Pizza • Best For Linger-Worthy Dinners
Salvatore’s delivers classic Italian comfort, where pizza shares the spotlight with pastas, salads, and a relaxed dining room.
If you want pizza but also want to make a night of it, Salvatore’s is an easy pick just outside Warren proper. The pizzas come with a thinner, nicely browned crust and thoughtful topping combos, and you can round things out with appetizers, pasta, or a glass of wine. It’s a comfortable choice for date night, family gatherings, or celebrating after a game in Howland.
04
Best carryout spot
Franky's Pizza & Delicatessen
North Warren Neighborhood • Pizza And Deli Counter • Slice-And-Sub Specialist
Franky’s is a compact counter-serve shop known for hearty pizzas, subs, and fast, friendly carryout.
Franky’s feels like the kind of small neighborhood place every town should have: a short menu, steady foot traffic, and boxes heading out the door all evening. The pies skew hearty, with lots of cheese and classic toppings, and you can easily tack on deli-style subs or wings to feed a crowd. It’s especially handy when you want a no-fuss pickup on the way home or before a movie night in.
05
Neighborhood hidden gem
Carmen's Pizza
Southwest Warren Side Streets • No-Frills Neighborhood Pizzeria • Under-The-Radar Local Favorite
Carmen’s turns out unfussy, well-made pies in a low-key setting that keeps nearby neighbors coming back.
Carmen’s doesn’t chase trends; it focuses on solid dough, plenty of cheese, and straightforward toppings done right. The atmosphere is modest, but that’s part of the appeal if you care more about what’s in the box than what’s on the walls. It’s a smart choice when you want a classic-style pizza that tastes homemade without having to flour your own counter.