01
Best overall pick
Crowtown Pizza
Near Downtown Coshocton • Small-Town Pizza Parlor • Local Favorite
A cozy Coshocton standby with hearty, topping-heavy pies that feel made for small-town Ohio appetites.
Crowtown Pizza is the kind of place locals recommend first when you ask where to get a good pie near Warsaw. The crust lands in that sweet spot between soft and sturdy, with plenty of cheese and generous toppings that hold up well on the drive back to the village. It is an easy choice when you want something that tastes a bit more hometown than chain.
02
Best for fast delivery
Domino's Pizza
Coshocton Commercial Strip • Delivery-Focused Chain • Fast Delivery Standby
A go-to for quick, customizable pizzas and late-evening orders within a short hop of Warsaw.
For nights when convenience matters more than lingering over a sit-down meal, Domino’s in Coshocton is hard to beat. Online ordering and tracking make it easy to time your pick-up on the way home or have a hot pizza show up at the door. The menu is broad enough that everyone in the group can land on something, from classic hand-tossed to specialty pies and sides.
03
Best for families
Pizza Hut
South Coshocton • Family-Friendly Dine-In Chain • Best For Sit-Down Dinners
Classic pan pizzas, roomy booths, and a familiar menu make this an easy family choice after a day out.
If you are looking to sit down with the kids or meet relatives halfway, the Pizza Hut in Coshocton offers a familiar, relaxed setting. Thick pan crusts, stuffed crust options, and sharable sides like breadsticks and wings make ordering for a group straightforward. It is a comfortable, no-surprises spot when you want to linger over pizza instead of rushing back to the car.
04
Best Ohio-style slices
Creno's Pizza
Coshocton Neighborhood Spot • Ohio-Style Pizzeria • Best For Classic Ohio-Style Pies
A regional favorite known for square-cut pies, a slightly sweet sauce, and plenty of topping combos.
Creno’s brings a distinctly Ohio-style take to the area, with pizzas typically cut into squares and built on a sturdy crust that holds up under cheese and toppings. The sauce leans a touch sweet, which many locals love, especially on traditional pepperoni and sausage orders. It is a solid pick when you want something that feels regional rather than generic chain fare.
05
Best takeout from the next town over
East of Chicago Pizza
West Lafayette • Carryout And Delivery Shop • Best For Weeknight Takeout
Thick, topping-loaded pizzas and frequent specials make this West Lafayette shop worth the quick drive from Warsaw.
Just down the road in West Lafayette, East of Chicago is a handy option when you want a substantial, thick-crust pizza without driving all the way into Coshocton. They are known for piling on the cheese and toppings, plus running deals that work well for feeding a crowd. It is especially convenient for Warsaw residents on the west side of the river who want a quick grab-and-go dinner.