01
Best overall pick
Pisanello's Pizza of Waterville
Downtown Waterville • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A cozy downtown staple known for generous toppings and friendly, small-town service.
Pisanello’s sits right in the heart of Waterville and feels like the kind of pizzeria every small town hopes to have. The menu leans into classic, crowd-pleasing pies along with subs, salads, and sides that make it easy to feed a group. It’s a go-to option when you want that familiar hometown flavor without overthinking your order.
02
Best for big orders
Tano's Pizza
Michigan Avenue Corridor • Carryout And Delivery Shop • Great For Families And Teams
A reliable stop for hearty, shareable pizzas that travel well for parties, movie nights, and team dinners.
Tano’s is the place locals call when they need a stack of boxes for a birthday, team celebration, or busy weeknight. The crust is sturdy enough to hold plenty of toppings, and the menu covers the basics with pepperoni-heavy pies, cheesy bread, and wings. It’s more practical than fancy, but that straightforward approach is exactly what makes it work for big groups.
03
Best national-chain comfort
Pizza Hut
Pray Boulevard Shopping Area • Casual Chain Carryout And Dine-In • Reliable Crowd-Pleaser
Familiar pan pizzas and stuffed crust favorites in a convenient shopping-area location.
The Waterville Pizza Hut is an easy choice when you want classic chain comfort food that everyone already knows. Pan, hand-tossed, and stuffed crust options make it simple to please picky eaters, and the wings and pasta round out a one-stop order. It’s especially handy if you’re already running errands nearby and want to grab dinner on the way home.
04
Best for customized pies
Marco's Pizza
Waterville East Side • Fast-Casual Pizza Chain • Build-Your-Own Specialist
A fast-moving shop where you can tailor pizzas with lots of topping and crust options.
Marco’s gives you plenty of flexibility, from classic pepperoni to build-your-own combinations with different meats, veggies, and sauces. The menu also leans into subs, cheesy bread, and salads, making it easy to mix and match for a household with different tastes. It’s a smart pick when you want something quick and consistent but still a bit more tailored than a standard one-size-fits-all order.
05
Worth-the-drive pick
Crust Pizzeria
Downtown Whitehouse, Short Drive South • Modern Craft Pizzeria • Best Nearby For Gourmet Toppings
A short drive from Waterville rewards you with thoughtfully made pies and a more contemporary pizzeria feel.
Crust Pizzeria in nearby Whitehouse is the place to go when you’re in the mood to make pizza the focus of the outing, not just a quick meal. The menu leans toward more crafted combinations and a slightly more modern atmosphere than the typical carryout joint. It’s a great option for a relaxed night out or when you want a step up from everyday takeout without heading all the way into Toledo.