01
Best overall pick
Fred's Pizza Italian
West Emmitt Avenue Corridor • Old-School Italian-American Pizzeria • Hometown Classic For Sit-Down Or Carryout
A long-running local favorite known for hearty, pan-style pies and a crowd-pleasing menu.
Fred’s feels like the kind of place locals grow up on, with thick, cheesy pizzas and generous toppings that lean into comfort more than trendiness. The menu branches out into Italian-American staples, so it works well when not everyone at the table wants just pizza. It’s a strong all-around choice for families, small groups, and anyone who wants a relaxed, no-rush meal along the main strip.
02
For specialty pies
Cardo's Pizza
South Side Of Waverly • Family-Friendly Pizza And Subs Shop • Best For Loaded Specialty And Party Pizzas
Cardo’s leans into big, creatively topped pizzas that are ideal for sharing on game days and birthdays.
Known for its specialty combinations and oversized pies, Cardo’s is where locals go when a plain pepperoni just won’t cut it. The crust runs on the thicker, chewier side, built to handle piles of toppings without getting soggy. Pair a couple of their signature pizzas with wings or cheesy bread and you’ve got an easy crowd-feeding plan without a lot of fuss.
03
Great for groups
Giovanni's Pizza
West Emmitt Avenue Near Us-23 • Casual Regional Pizzeria • Best For Customizable Orders And Big Appetites
Giovanni’s offers a flexible lineup of pizzas, subs, and sides that works well when a whole group is ordering.
With a wide range of toppings, crust options, and sizes, Giovanni’s makes it easy to build exactly the kind of pizza night you want. It’s popular for carryout and delivery when families or coworkers need something everyone can agree on. Add in their subs and sides and you can mix and match enough options to keep even picky eaters satisfied.
04
Neighborhood gem
Lloyd's Pizzeria
Central Waverly Neighborhood • No-Frills Hometown Pizza Shop • Best For A Classic, Locally Owned Slice
Lloyd’s keeps things simple with well-made, traditional pies that focus on crust, sauce, and cheese.
This is the kind of spot where the staff gets to know regulars and the pizza tastes the same in the best way every time you stop in. Expect straightforward toppings, a satisfying crust, and that slightly sweet, savory sauce profile many Ohio pizza fans look for. It’s a strong pick when you want a reliably good, local pie without any bells and whistles.
05
Chain comfort choice
Pizza Hut
East Emmitt Avenue Near Shopping • Familiar National Chain Pizzeria • Best For Predictable Pan Pizza And Quick Deals
Waverly’s Pizza Hut delivers the brand’s familiar pan and stuffed-crust pies with convenient carryout and delivery.
If you already know exactly how you like your Pizza Hut order, this location delivers that same experience with easy access off the main road. It’s especially handy for weeknight dinners, kids’ sleepovers, or anytime you want predictable pizza with frequent bundle deals. While it may not be the most unique choice in town, its consistency and convenience keep it in regular local rotation.