01
Best overall pick
Bud's Pizza
Downtown Wapakoneta • Old-School Downtown Pizzeria • Classic Local Favorite
A Wapakoneta institution turning out nostalgic, square-cut pies that many locals grew up on.
If you ask people in Auglaize County where they got pizza as a kid, Bud's comes up fast. Expect thin, crispy, square-cut pizzas with a sauce that leans a little sweet and plenty of cheese. It is the kind of no-frills, packed-on-weekends spot that rewards sticking to classic toppings and sharing a big pie at a corner table.
02
Top carryout choice
Fat Jack's Pizza
East Wapakoneta • Carryout And Delivery Pizza Shop • Best For Big, Cheesy Carryout
Go-to place when you want a hot, heavy-on-the-cheese pizza run out to the car or your doorstep.
Fat Jack's is built for busy weeknights and ballgame parties, with generous toppings and reliably gooey cheese. The crust lands between thin and thick, sturdy enough to hold loaded specialty combinations without getting soggy. Call ahead, grab a couple of large pies and some breadsticks, and you are set for feeding a crowd back in Waynesfield.
03
Coziest dine-in pick
Guarnieri Pizzeria
Downtown St. Marys • Tavern-Style Italian Pizzeria • Best For Laid-Back Nights Out
A relaxed, old-school pizzeria where thin-crust pies and cold drinks anchor an unhurried evening.
In downtown St. Marys, Guarnieri feels like the kind of place regulars claim as their own. Pizzas come out on the thinner side, with crisp edges and plenty of flavor, especially if you lean into the sausage and pepperoni. It is an easy choice when you want to sit down, chat over a few slices, and skip the chain-restaurant feel.
04
Best for groups and games
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill
Shawnee / West Lima • Lively Pizza Grill And Sports Bar • Best For Groups And Game Days
Big, bustling spot pairing hefty pizzas with a full grill menu, lots of taps, and sports on nearly every screen.
If you are willing to make the short drive up toward Lima, Beer Barrel is where pizza meets full-on night out. The menu runs from classic pepperoni to loaded specialty pies, plus wings, burgers, and plenty of appetizers for sharing. With roomy booths, long tables, and TVs everywhere, it works especially well for family get-togethers and game-day gatherings.
05
Most convenient highway stop
Padrone's Pizza
Near I-75 In Wapakoneta • Quick-Stop Local Pizza Chain • Best Value Near The Highway
Fast, reliable pies with good value combos for anyone slipping off I-75 or heading back through Wapakoneta.
Padrone's is a smart move when you want something better than generic gas-station food but do not have time for a sit-down meal. The crust is classic Ohio carryout style, and the menu hits all the standards plus a few hearty specialty options. It is particularly handy for grabbing a couple of pizzas on your way home to Waynesfield after a day on the road.