01
Best overall pick
Pizza House
Historic Downtown Wellington • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria • Go-To Main Street Slice
A long-running Main Street staple serving generous, straightforward pies that feel tailor-made for small-town pizza night.
Pizza House is the spot locals mention first when you ask where to grab a pie in Wellington. The menu leans classic—think pepperoni, sausage, and extra cheese—done with a reliable hand and plenty of toppings. It’s the kind of place where a single large pizza and an order of breadsticks can easily anchor a family dinner or a casual gathering with friends.
02
Best for hearty carryout
Checkers Pizza
Village Edge Of Wellington • Hearty Carryout And Delivery Shop • Loaded-Toppings Favorite
Known for thickly topped pies and big portions, Checkers is a dependable choice when you want to feed a crowd without fuss.
Checkers Pizza leans into the comfort-food side of the spectrum, with pies that arrive hot, cheesy, and stacked with toppings. It’s a popular option for game nights and last-minute gatherings when you need a couple of large pizzas and wings fast. Expect friendly, no-frills service and straightforward flavors that appeal to just about everyone at the table.
03
Best for late-night delivery
Domino's Pizza
South Main Street Corridor • National Chain With Fast Delivery • Reliable Late-Night Option
This South Main outpost delivers the familiar Domino’s lineup, making it a handy choice for busy weeknights and late cravings.
While it’s a national chain, the local Domino’s earns its place on the list thanks to consistent, quick delivery across the Wellington area. The menu is ideal when everyone wants something different, with customizable pizzas, pastas, and specialty pies. It’s especially useful on weeknights or after events when you want dinner handled with a couple of taps and a short wait.
04
Best short-drive sit-down
Lorenzo's Pizzeria
Downtown Oberlin • Sit-Down Italian Restaurant And Pizzeria • Worth-The-Drive Dinner Spot
A few miles north in Oberlin, Lorenzo’s offers classic pizzas alongside pastas and salads in a cozy, college-town setting.
If you don’t mind a short drive, Lorenzo’s in downtown Oberlin rewards you with a broader Italian menu and a relaxed dining room. The pizza leans traditional, with a well-browned crust and balanced sauce-to-cheese ratio that pairs nicely with a simple salad. It’s a nice option when you want something a bit more leisurely than grab-and-go, especially before or after a stroll around the square.
05
Best for crispy-crust takeout
Gionino's Pizzeria
Village Center Of Lagrange • Neighborhood Chain-Style Pizzeria • Crust-Focused Carryout Pick
Gionino’s in nearby LaGrange is loved for its crisp-edged crust, bold cheese blend, and crowd-pleasing specialty pies.
This regional favorite is a smart choice when you’re already out toward LaGrange or planning a pizza stop on the way home. The pizzas are known for their sturdy, crisp crust that holds up well under heavier toppings, making them ideal for meat-lovers and supreme-style orders. Add in their wings and JoJo-style potato wedges, and you have an easy, one-stop takeout spread.