01
Best overall pick
Pizza Pub and Patio
Downtown Wellston • Lively Pizza Pub • Local Favorite For Dine-In
A downtown hangout where the pizza comes hot, the portions are generous, and the atmosphere feels unmistakably local.
Set on West Broadway, Pizza Pub and Patio is the spot where Wellston locals meet up for a laid-back night of pizza, wings, and cold drinks. The pies are hearty with plenty of toppings, and the crust strikes a middle ground between soft and crisp that works well for sharing. Grab a booth or a patio table, linger over a pitcher, and you’ll get a good feel for the town while you eat.
02
Best for delivery night
Domino's Pizza
South Wellston • National Delivery Chain • Reliable Late-Night Delivery
A go-to option when you want predictable, fast delivery pizza without leaving the couch.
Located on South Pennsylvania Avenue, Wellston’s Domino’s is the obvious call for busy weeknights and game-day orders. The menu covers everything from customizable hand-tossed and thin-crust pies to wings, pasta, and desserts, so it’s easy to please a mixed group. Order ahead online or by phone and pick up at the counter if you’re already out running errands.
03
Best small-town classic
Brennan Family Pizzeria
East Wellston Neighborhood • Family-Run Carryout Shop • Neighborhood Standby
A modest, family-run spot that focuses on straightforward, crowd-pleasing pizzas and subs.
Brennan Family Pizzeria leans into the simple comforts of small-town pizza: familiar toppings, plenty of cheese, and crusts that hold up well for carryout. It’s the kind of place where regulars know the staff and orders are often the same week after week. Call ahead, grab a couple of large pies and some subs, and you’ve got an easy dinner ready to take home.
04
Best for big groups and game nights
Cardo's Pizza & Pasta
Jackson, About 10 Miles West • Classic Ohio-Style Pie And Pasta Shop • Regional Favorite Worth The Drive
A regional chain known for square-cut, Ohio-style pizzas that works well for sharing with a crowd.
A short drive over to Jackson brings you to Cardo’s, where the pizzas arrive in classic Midwestern fashion: cut into squares with a slightly sweet sauce and a generous layer of cheese. The menu also includes pasta dishes, salads, and sandwiches, making it easy to feed a mixed group without much debate. It’s a solid option when you’ve got a car full of hungry people after a game or a day out.
05
Best for variety
Giovanni's Pizza
Jackson, Just Off Main Street • Casual Hometown Pizzeria • Great For Big Appetites
A casual Jackson staple offering loaded specialty pizzas, wings, and hearty sides in a no-frills setting.
Giovanni’s in Jackson is a popular choice when you’re in the mood for a big, topping-heavy pie and maybe a basket of wings on the side. Specialty pizzas, from classic meat combos to veggie-forward options, make it easy to order for a group without overthinking it. The vibe is straightforward and family-friendly, ideal for a relaxed meal after making the quick drive from Wellston.