01
Best overall pick
Pizza Hut
Main Street In Wellsville • Family-Friendly Chain Pizzeria • Reliable All-Rounder
A convenient Main Street staple offering familiar pies, wings, and pasta for both dine-in and takeout.
For many Wellsville residents, this is the default choice when someone says, “Let’s just get a pizza.” The menu is broad enough to keep a family happy, from customizable pan pizzas to wings and breadsticks. It’s also one of the most dependable options in town for late-evening carryout after practices, meetings, or riverfront events.
02
Classic small-town carryout
Glasgow Carry Out
South Of Wellsville Toward Glasgow • Takeout Pizza And Convenience Stop • Best Grab-And-Go Option
A no-frills carryout where locals swing by for hearty pizzas alongside subs and snacks.
Glasgow Carry Out feels like the kind of place you only know about if someone local tells you. The pizza leans toward the hearty, load-it-up style, with generous toppings that make it ideal for feeding a crowd. It’s a smart choice when you want to pick up a couple of pies and some extras on the way home without making a full night of it.
03
Go-to hometown pie
Nick's Pizza
Residential Side Streets Of Wellsville • Neighborhood Pizza Shop • Local Favorite
A small, homey spot known for straightforward, satisfying pizzas that taste like they were made for regulars.
Nick’s has that low-key, hometown feel where the focus stays on the pie rather than the décor. Expect classic toppings, familiar combinations, and a crust that holds up well on the drive home. It’s the kind of place people grow up with and keep going back to whenever they’re back in town.
04
Worth the short drive
Casa De Emanuel
East Liverpool Riverfront District • Old-School Italian Restaurant With Pizza • Best Sit-Down Experience
A longtime East Liverpool favorite where you can pair a classic pizza with Italian dinners in a cozy dining room.
If you’re willing to drive a few minutes north along the river, Casa De Emanuel delivers a full Italian restaurant feel with pizza that holds its own. Many locals come here for pasta or chicken dishes and tack on a pizza to share at the table. It’s a good choice when you want a relaxed, lingering meal rather than a quick box-and-go night.
05
Fast and familiar chain
Domino's Pizza
East Liverpool Hilltop Commercial Strip • Delivery-Focused Chain Pizzeria • Best For Late-Night Delivery
A dependable East Liverpool outpost offering quick delivery of customizable pizzas, sides, and desserts.
When convenience and speed matter most, this Domino’s location is a go-to for many Wellsville and East Liverpool households. Online ordering, frequent deals, and consistent delivery make it especially useful for game nights, study sessions, or last-minute dinners. It may not be the most romantic pick, but it’s hard to argue with hot pizza on your doorstep in short order.