01
Best overall pick
Kathy's Homemade Pizza - Camden
Camden • Small-Town Carryout Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A tiny Camden staple turning out thick, cheesy pies and loaded subs just a few minutes west of West Elkton.
Kathy's in Camden is the kind of no-frills carryout spot locals grow up on, with a crust that’s sturdy enough for heavy toppings and a sauce that leans just a bit sweet. It’s ideal when you want a big, shareable pie for movie night or a quick pickup before heading back out into the country. Call ahead on busy weekends; it can get slammed with local orders.
02
Best for families
Sarah's Pizza - West Alexandria
West Alexandria • Classic Family Pizza Parlor • Best For Families
A friendly small-town parlor with generous pizzas, wings, and pasta, perfect for a relaxed family dinner.
Sarah's Pizza in West Alexandria feels like a community living room, with plenty of seating and a menu that keeps kids and adults happy. The hand-tossed pies, loaded salads, and shareable appetizers make it easy to linger over a meal after games or events. It’s a short drive north of West Elkton and a reliable option when you want more than just a quick carryout box.
03
Best classic Ohio-style
Richard's Pizza - Trenton
Trenton • Old-School Hometown Pizzeria • Best For Classic Ohio-Style Pizza
A Butler County institution known for thin, edge-to-edge toppings and its famous steak sandwich alongside the pizza.
Richard's in Trenton draws fans from all over the area, and it’s one of the closest ways for West Elkton pizza lovers to tap into that Butler County tradition. The pizzas are cut into squares, with toppings spread right out to the crust for a snackable, shareable pie. Pair a pepperoni or deluxe pizza with their signature steak sandwich if you’re feeding a hungry crowd.
04
Best college-town vibe
LaRosa's Pizzeria - Oxford
Oxford Near Campus • Lively Family-Friendly Chain Pizzeria • Best For A Night Out
Cincinnati’s classic family pizza name in a busy college-town setting, with plenty of variety and a buzzy atmosphere.
LaRosa's in Oxford sits right in the mix of Miami University energy, making it a fun change of pace from quieter village spots. The menu runs deep, from build-your-own pies and specialty pizzas to calzones, hoagies, and pasta, so it’s easy to keep a group satisfied. It’s a good pick if you’re already in Oxford for a game, concert, or campus visit and want a familiar, crowd-pleasing option.
05
Best value pick
All8Up Pizza & Hoagies - Middletown
Middletown • Neighborhood Pizza And Hoagie Shop • Best Value Slices And Subs
A laid-back Middletown joint serving hearty, budget-friendly pizzas and overstuffed hoagies within an easy drive of West Elkton.
All8Up is the kind of place where a couple of large pizzas and a tray of hoagies can feed a whole crew without breaking the bank. The crust has a satisfying chew, and they don’t skimp on cheese or toppings, making even the basic pepperoni feel like a solid upgrade from chain delivery. It’s a smart choice for casual get-togethers, work lunches, or stocking the table for game day.