01
Classic institution
Sunrise Inn
Downtown Warren • Classic Italian Tavern And Pizzeria • Local Institution
A Warren landmark known for hearty tavern-style pies and Brier Hill pizza, worth the drive from West Farmington.
Sunrise Inn is the kind of old-school spot people in Trumbull County grow up on, with pizzas that lean generous on toppings and cheese. The Brier Hill pie, layered with peppers and Romano, is a regional specialty you won’t see many other places. Go when you have time to sit, order a round of pies for the table, and soak up the vintage neighborhood-bar atmosphere.
02
Closest classic takeout
Capps Pizza
Bristolville Town Center • Small-Town Carryout Pizza Shop • Best For Quick Takeout
A convenient nearby option for West Farmington locals looking for reliable, cheesy pies without driving into the city.
Capps Pizza in Bristolville is a go-to when you want a straightforward, well-loaded pizza and you want it close to home. Crusts run on the thicker, Midwest style, built to hold a lot of toppings and extra cheese. Call ahead on busy nights, grab a couple of pies and wings, and you’re set for a low-key evening in.
03
Sit-down favorite
Joey's Italian Grille
Middlefield Strip • Family Italian Restaurant With Pizza • Best For Sit-Down Dinners
A family-friendly Italian spot in Middlefield where the pizzas are as popular as the pastas and wings.
Joey’s Italian Grille gives you a full Italian menu, but locals know the pizza is one of the main draws. The crust has a nice balance of chew and crisp, and you can go classic pepperoni or build something more loaded to share. It’s an easy choice when you’ve got a mixed group craving both pizza and traditional red-sauce plates in one stop.
04
Hearty pan-pizza pick
Gionino's Pizzeria
Cortland Neighborhood Strip • Neighborhood Delivery And Carryout Joint • Best For Big Groups
A Northeast Ohio chain known for thick, cheesy pies and big orders of JoJo potatoes that feed a crowd.
Gionino’s in Cortland is built for nights when the whole family or a group of friends is hungry at once. The pizzas are substantial, with a sturdy crust, lots of cheese, and crowd-pleasing topping combos that travel well. Add in their JoJo potatoes and fried chicken, and you can cover more than just the pizza cravings in a single delivery.
05
Familiar family option
Pizza Hut
Middlefield Shopping Corridor • National Family Pizza Chain • Best For Familiar Favorites
A reliable chain stop where West Farmington families know exactly what kind of pan and stuffed-crust pizzas they’ll get.
Middlefield’s Pizza Hut is a practical choice when you want predictable favorites and plenty of coupons to stretch a budget. The menu covers pan, hand-tossed, and stuffed crusts, plus wings and pasta that kids tend to latch onto. Order ahead for carryout on the way home or settle into a booth for a no-surprises, family-night meal.