01
Best overall pick
Flyers Pizza & Subs
Historic Main Street • Classic Ohio-Style Pizzeria • Local Favorite
A Main Street staple with consistently good pies, a friendly dine-in vibe, and plenty of options beyond pizza.
Flyers is the place most locals mention first when you ask where to get pizza in West Jefferson. The menu leans into Ohio-style pies with a sturdy crust, edge-to-edge toppings, and reliable standards like pepperoni and deluxe combos. It works just as well for a quick lunch buffet as it does for a sit-down family dinner or team celebration.
02
Best pizza-and-pub combo
Pat's Pizza & Pub
West Jefferson Town Center • Family-Friendly Pizza Pub • Best For Groups
Lively pub energy with better-than-expected pizza, cold drinks, and space for a crowd.
Pat’s pairs a solid lineup of pizzas with the feel of a small-town pub, making it an easy choice when some people want a meal and others just want a drink and a snack. The crust is on the heartier side, with plenty of topping combinations and the option to go a little lighter or heavier depending on your appetite. It’s a comfortable spot for gathering after a game, catching up with friends, or easing into a low-key weekend night out.
03
Best for wings with your pizza
Bambino's Pizza and Wings
Route 40 Corridor • Casual Pizza And Wings Joint • Game-Day Pick
A go-to for hearty pies and saucy wings when you’re settling in to watch the game at home.
Bambino’s leans into comfort food, serving generous pizzas alongside a big roster of wings, making it ideal when you’re feeding a hungry group. The pizza skews classic and crowd-pleasing, with plenty of cheese and a crust that holds up well under heavier toppings. Order a couple of different sauces on the wings and a couple of large pies and you’re set for any game-day spread or casual get-together.
04
Classic carryout choice
Mike's Pizza
West Town Street Strip • Neighborhood Carryout Pizzeria • Takeout Go-To
Old-school, no-frills pizza and subs that hit the spot when you just want hot, straightforward comfort food.
Mike’s feels like the kind of small-town pizza shop that’s been part of weeknight routines for years, with a menu built around familiar favorites. The pizzas are straightforward and satisfying, and the subs and sandwiches make it easy to please that one person in the group who is not in a pizza mood. It’s a dependable choice when you’re grabbing dinner on the way home or need something easy for a movie night in.
05
Laid-back family stop
Todd's Pizza Restaurant
East Side Of The Village • Sit-Down Family Pizzeria • Best For Families
A relaxed, family-oriented spot where you can linger over pizzas, salads, and other Italian-American staples.
Todd’s offers the kind of unhurried dining room that works well for families with kids or anyone who prefers to eat their pizza off a real plate rather than from a box. Expect classic toppings, shareable pies, and a few extra pasta or dinner options to round out the table. It’s the sort of place where staff learn regulars’ orders and you can count on an easy, low-stress meal.