01
Best overall pick
White Eyes Pizza & Carry Out
Just East Of West Lafayette • Family-Run Carryout Pizzeria • Go-To Local Favorite
A small, friendly shop known for hearty pies, crispy crust, and reliable takeout for the whole crew.
White Eyes feels like the kind of country carryout people grow up with and keep coming back to. The pizzas are generously topped, the crust has just enough chew, and the menu stays focused on the basics done well. Call ahead on busy nights; locals know this is the dependable choice when everyone is hungry.
02
Reliable classic
Pizza Hut
In The Village On South 2Nd Street • National Chain With Local Crowd • Best For Familiar Favorites
A village standby where you can count on the same pan, hand-tossed, and stuffed-crust standards you find anywhere in the country.
This is the spot when you want a no-surprises pizza night with all the usual Pizza Hut options. Families lean on it for combo deals, stuffed crust, and wings, and it is an easy choice when you are feeding a group with mixed tastes. Online ordering and predictable timing make it especially handy on busy weeknights.
03
Local flavor in town
Crowtown Pizza
Downtown Coshocton • Casual Small-Town Pizzeria • Worth The Short Drive
A cozy Coshocton shop turning out well-seasoned, slightly chewy crusts and topping combinations that feel a bit more local than chain fare.
Crowtown Pizza has the easygoing feel of a neighborhood hangout, with a crust that holds up under plenty of toppings and sauce that leans flavorful instead of overly sweet. It is a nice change of pace if you usually stick to national chains and want something that feels rooted in town. Pair a specialty pie with a simple salad and you have a relaxed, affordable night out.
04
Fast delivery choice
Domino's Pizza
Coshocton Commercial Strip • Busy Delivery-Focused Shop • Best For Late-Night Delivery
Quick to the door with customizable crusts and sauces, Domino's is the workhorse option when convenience matters most.
With its streamlined online ordering and frequent coupon deals, the Coshocton Domino's is a practical pick for last-minute pizza runs. You can dial in your order with different crusts, extra cheese, and add-ons like cheesy bread or pasta to stretch a meal. It is not fancy, but when you want something hot, fast, and predictable, it gets the job done.
05
Scenic getaway slice
Rainbow Hills Winery, Brewery Pizzeria & Inn
Hills South Of West Lafayette • Winery Restaurant With Stone-Fired Pizza • Best For A Relaxed Evening Out
Rustic pizzas, local wine and beer, and wooded hillside views turn a simple pie into a lingering night away from town.
Rainbow Hills is where you go when you want your pizza with a view instead of a TV overhead. The crust comes out crisp around the edges, toppings are thoughtfully chosen to pair with their wines and house beers, and the pace invites you to slow down. It is an easy recommendation for date night, out-of-town guests, or anyone who wants to make an evening of it rather than just grabbing a box to go.