01
Best overall pick
Six Hundred Downtown
Downtown Bellefontaine • Wood-Fired Neapolitan Pizzeria • Destination For Pizza Purists
Award-winning brick-oven pies in a lively historic-downtown setting.
Six Hundred Downtown is the spot locals point to when they say you have to try pizza around here. The menu leans into classic Neapolitan-style pies with blistered, chewy crusts and well-balanced toppings, plus seasonal specials that keep regulars curious. It is worth the quick drive from West Liberty, especially if you pair your pizza with a stroll around Bellefontaine's revitalized downtown.
02
Best for big groups
Donatos Pizza
East Bellefontaine • Thin-Crust Ohio Chain Pizzeria • Best For Families And Teams
Crisp, edge-to-edge topping pizzas that are easy to share with a crowd.
Donatos in Bellefontaine is a go-to when you are feeding a carload of kids or a whole ball team after a game. The signature thin crust holds up well under generous toppings, and the square-cut slices make it simple to stretch a couple of larges. Add in salads, subs, and wings, and you can cover picky eaters without overthinking the order.
03
Old-school favorite
Cassano's Pizza King
South Bellefontaine • Dayton-Style Party-Cut Pizzeria • Classic Local Standby
Thin, square-cut pies with a nostalgic, old-school Ohio pizzeria feel.
Cassano's Pizza King brings that classic Dayton-style pie that many locals grew up on. Expect a cracker-thin crust, toppings spread right to the edge, and pizzas cut into small squares made for sharing around a table. It is the kind of spot that feels familiar on your first visit, ideal for a relaxed, no-fuss pizza night after a day out near West Liberty.
04
Best hometown feel
Sparky's Pizzeria & Deli
East Urbana • Casual Pizzeria And Deli • Cozy Hometown Hangout
Laid-back pies and subs in a spot that feels like a true local hangout.
Sparky's in Urbana mixes solid, satisfying pizza with a full lineup of subs and deli-style sides. The atmosphere is relaxed and neighborly, with plenty of regulars grabbing dinner or a quick lunch. It is an easy detour from West Liberty when you want something low-key but still very local, especially if you like to mix pizza slices with a good sub sandwich.
05
Late-night lifesaver
Domino's Pizza
North Urbana • National Delivery Chain • Late-Night And Delivery Pick
Fast, customizable pizzas with reliable delivery when you do not feel like driving far.
When convenience is the priority, the Domino's in Urbana is often the most straightforward choice from West Liberty. The app makes it easy to customize crusts, sauces, and toppings, and you can track your order while you wait. It is especially handy on busy weeknights or after evening events when a hot pizza showing up at the door beats another drive.