01
Best overall pick
Pizza Crossing
Downtown Logan • Classic Small-Town Pizzeria • Local Institution For Sit-Down Pizza
The go-to downtown spot for generous pies, cold drinks, and a lively small-town dining room.
If you ask around Logan where to get pizza, Pizza Crossing is the name you’ll hear most often. The crust is sturdy enough to hold plenty of toppings, and the sauce leans classic and crowd-pleasing rather than fussy. It’s a comfortable place to linger over a pitcher with friends, but they handle big carryout orders smoothly, too.
02
Best for groups and carryout
Cristy's Pizza
West Side Of Logan • Carryout-Focused Pizza Shop • Best For Feeding A Crowd
A west-side standby known for consistent pies, value-friendly specials, and easy pickup on the way home.
Cristy’s is the kind of place locals rely on when they’re ordering for a game night, team party, or family gathering. The menu runs through all the familiar toppings plus hearty specialty combinations, with subs and wings to round things out. Call ahead, swing by the counter, and you’ll be back over the river to West Logan with hot boxes in just a few minutes.
03
Best post-hike stop
Captain Ron's Pirate Pizza
Hocking Hills Caves Corridor • Quirky Pirate-Themed Pizzeria • Fun Pick Near The Parks
A playful pirate-themed stop serving hearty pies, subs, and ice cream just up the road from the caves.
Captain Ron’s sits right along the main Hocking Hills route, making it an easy reward after a day at Old Man’s Cave or Cedar Falls. The pizza is built for hungry hikers—well-loaded and satisfying without being fussy. Kids love the theme and the ice cream counter, while adults appreciate having a casual, locally owned option so close to the trails.
04
Best for late-night delivery
Domino's Pizza
By The Logan Shopping Strip • National Chain With Speedy Delivery • Most Reliable Fast Delivery
Chain pizza done as expected, with fast delivery across Logan and over to West Logan when you just want something easy.
When it’s late, the weather’s bad, or everyone is too tired from hiking to go back out, Domino’s is the default option for many locals and cabin guests. The app ordering, frequent coupons, and build-your-own combinations make it especially weeknight-friendly. It may not be unique to Logan, but the convenience factor is hard to beat.
05
Best small-town detour
Laurelville Pizza
Downtown Laurelville • Laid-Back Village Pizza Joint • Worth-The-Drive Regional Favorite
A simple, friendly shop in nearby Laurelville that feels like a classic Hocking Hills pizza stop.
If you don’t mind a short drive through the hills, Laurelville Pizza offers that old-school, no-rush vibe that’s getting harder to find. Expect straightforward pies with plenty of cheese, familiar toppings, and an emphasis on takeout with a few seats for those who want to linger. It pairs nicely with a scenic loop through the back roads between West Logan and the southern edge of the park.