01
Best overall pick
Six Hundred Downtown
Downtown Bellefontaine • Wood-Fired Neapolitan Pizzeria • Destination-Worthy Standout
Serious, competition-level pizzas baked in a blazing hot oven right on Bellefontaine's main street.
If you are willing to make one short drive for pizza, make it to Six Hundred Downtown. The crust comes out blistered and chewy with classic Neapolitan toppings and a few fun, chef-y specials that change with the seasons. It feels more like a destination restaurant than a small-town pizzeria, so it works just as well for date night as it does for a splurge-y family outing.
02
Thin-crust favorite
Donatos Pizza
East Side Of Bellefontaine • Thin-Crust Ohio Pizza Chain • Family-Friendly Carryout
Famous for edge-to-edge toppings on a super-thin crust, ideal for feeding a crew without much fuss.
Bellefontaine's Donatos is a go-to when you want predictable, crispy thin-crust pies that still feel like a treat. Toppings are loaded from edge to edge, so every slice tastes like the "good piece" from the middle of the box. Add in salads, subs, and wings, and it is an easy one-stop option when you are picking up dinner on the way back to West Mansfield.
03
Lively night out
Benny's Pizza Pub & Patio
Marysville East Side • Bustling Pizza Pub With Large Patio • Best For Groups And Live Music
Big pizzas, a busy bar, and a sprawling patio that turns into a local hangout on warm nights.
Benny's in Marysville is where people head when pizza is just part of the plan. The menu leans classic and hearty, with plenty of shareable pies and appetizers that work well for big tables. In good weather, the patio and frequent live music make it feel more like a mini road-trip destination than a quick bite spot.
04
Hearty delivery pick
Padrone's Pizza
Central Marysville • Casual Neighborhood Delivery Shop • Toppings-Loaded Crowd-Pleaser
Generous cheese and toppings on sturdy crusts that hold up well for takeout or delivery back home.
Padrone's is the kind of spot that wins people over with sheer generosity: thick layers of cheese, plenty of toppings, and crust that stays satisfying even after a drive. Styles range from classic pepperoni to heavier specialty pies that eat like a full meal. It is a smart pick when you are ordering for hungry friends after a ball game or busy day on the road.
05
Best for variety
East of Chicago Pizza
South Bellefontaine • Pan And Buffet-Style Pizza Chain • Great For Big Appetites
Thick, saucy pan pizzas and lots of topping choices, ideal when everyone wants something a little different.
East of Chicago in Bellefontaine leans into comfort-food pizza with substantial pan and specialty pies. The crust is thicker and softer than most, with plenty of sauce and cheese, so a couple of slices go a long way. It is especially handy for families or mixed groups, since you can split a few different styles and let everyone claim a favorite slice.