01
Best overall pick
A.J.'s Heavenly Pizza
Fostoria Downtown • Family-Run Pizzeria • Local Favorite
Classic, generously topped pies and a friendly crew make this the go-to pizza stop closest to West Millgrove.
A.J.'s Heavenly Pizza is the kind of place where regulars are greeted by name and the dough is treated with respect. Crusts are chewy with just enough crisp, toppings are hearty, and the sauce leans comforting rather than trendy. It is a reliable choice for everything from a quick carryout dinner to a Friday-night family pizza run.
02
Worth the drive
Campus Pollyeyes
Near Bgsu Campus • College-Town Pizza Joint • Best For Big Groups
Famous stuffed breadsticks and hefty pizzas draw both students and out-of-towners to this Bowling Green staple.
Campus Pollyeyes is a ritual stop for anyone who has spent time around Bowling Green State University, and it is worth the extra miles from West Millgrove. The pizzas are substantial, but the signature move here is pairing them with the oversized, cheese-packed breadsticks that come out blistered and golden. Expect a bustling, casual vibe and portions built for sharing with a hungry crowd.
03
Laid-back hangout
Pizza Pub 516
Downtown Bowling Green • Laid-Back Pizza Pub • Best For Craft Beer And Pizza
A relaxed pub setting where crisp, flavorful pies share the spotlight with a solid tap list.
Pizza Pub 516 feels built for those nights when you want more than just a quick slice. The crust has some char and structure, making it a good canvas for creative topping combinations and specialty pies. With TVs, a rotating beer selection, and a steady local crowd, it is an easy meeting point for friends coming in from West Millgrove, Bowling Green, and beyond.
04
Game-day choice
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill
North Side Of Findlay • Spacious Sports-Bar Pizzeria • Best For Game Day
Big screens, big booths, and pan-style pizzas make this Findlay spot ideal for catching the game over a shared pie.
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill specializes in hearty, edge-to-edge pizzas with plenty of cheese and toppings, served in a roomy dining room that rarely feels cramped. It is a popular pick for watching sports, with a wall of TVs and a menu that stretches beyond pizza to wings, burgers, and appetizers. For West Millgrove residents, it turns a simple pizza run into an evening out with the whole crew.
05
Convenient carryout
Marco's Pizza
Fostoria East Side • Carryout And Delivery Chain • Takeout Standout
Reliable, customizable pizzas and fast service make this Fostoria location a go-to for weeknight delivery.
Marco's in Fostoria offers the familiarity of a well-known chain with enough options to keep regular orders interesting. From classic pepperoni to specialty builds with flavored crusts, it is easy to tailor pies for picky eaters or larger groups. The focus is on efficient carryout and delivery, which suits West Millgrove households looking for an easy pizza night without driving far.