01
Small-town classic
Tom's Pizza
South Miami Street, West Milton • Small-Town Pizza And Sub Shop • Local Icon
A long-running hometown favorite known for square-cut pies and hearty subs.
Tom’s is the kind of place West Milton families have been ordering from for generations, and the well-seasoned ovens show it in the crust. The pizzas are sturdy, generously topped, and perfect for feeding a crew without overcomplicating things. Grab a pie and a couple of subs and you’re set for a laid-back night in or an easy picnic at the park.
02
Cozy dine-in pick
Clark's Pizzeria
Central West Milton • Casual Dine-In Pizzeria • Best For Laid-Back Nights
A friendly sit-down spot where crisp crust and generous toppings draw regulars.
Clark’s feels like a true neighborhood pizzeria, with comfortable tables, friendly service, and pizza that lands right in the sweet spot between crisp and chewy. It’s an easy choice when you want to linger over a pie instead of rushing home with a box. Expect plenty of cheese, a solid sauce, and enough topping combos to keep everyone at the table happy.
03
Family-friendly choice
Fox's Pizza Den
Downtown West Milton • Family-Friendly Pizza Chain • Best For Families And Groups
A flexible option with big pizzas, subs, and wings that work well for groups and game nights.
This Fox’s Pizza Den franchise leans into crowd-pleasing hand-tossed pies, with sizes and specialty combinations made for sharing. The menu runs deep, so you can tack on wings, wedges, or a sub for the non-pizza people in the group. It’s the spot locals call when there’s a game on, kids to feed, and not much time to cook.
04
Destination thin crust
Marion's Piazza (Englewood)
Englewood Shopping Corridor • Dayton-Style Thin-Crust Institution • Worth-The-Drive Pick
A Dayton-area landmark serving ultra-thin, square-cut pizzas piled edge to edge with toppings.
About a 15–20 minute drive from West Milton, Marion’s in Englewood is the go-to when you want classic Dayton-style pizza done exactly right. The crust is cracker-thin, the pies are cut into tiny squares, and the toppings reach every corner of the pan. Huge dining rooms, quick service, and a steady buzz make it feel like a mini field trip even on a weeknight.
05
Carryout favorite
Cassano's Pizza King (Tipp City)
Historic Tipp City • Classic Regional Chain Pizzeria • Best For Carryout On The Go
A nearby outpost of the Dayton classic, known for its light sauce, thin crust, and square-cut pies.
Cassano’s in Tipp City is an easy swing-by if you’re already near I-75 or heading back toward West Milton from the south. The signature crust is thin and crisp, with a lighter tomato sauce and finely chopped toppings that make every bite feel balanced. It’s ideal for carryout when you want something that tastes like Dayton history but travels well in the box.