01
Best overall pick
Oddfellows
Downtown Portsmouth Riverfront • Craft Pizza And Bowling Lounge • Best For Groups
A lively spot where you can pair inventive pizzas with a few frames of bowling right in downtown Portsmouth.
Oddfellows feels like a night out wrapped around a really good pizza. The menu leans toward creative toppings and shareable pies, so it’s easy to mix and match for a group. Come for the pizza, stay for the games, and you’ve got an easy go-to when friends want something a little more fun than a standard sit-down dinner.
02
Old-school pan classic
Fred's Pizza Express
Gallia Street In Portsmouth • Old-School Pan-Pizza Joint • Classic Local Standby
A long-running Portsmouth favorite known for thick, cheesy pan pies and no-nonsense takeout.
If you grew up around Scioto County, there’s a good chance Fred’s was part of your pizza rotation. The crust is thick and satisfying, with that edge-of-the-pan crisp that deep-dish fans love. It’s an easy choice when you want a hearty, nostalgic pizza night just a short drive from West Portsmouth.
03
Buffet-friendly favorite
Giovanni's Pizza
11Th Street In Portsmouth • Casual Dine-In Pizza Parlor • Best For Big Appetites
A relaxed spot offering classic Giovanni's pies, pasta, and a popular buffet on select days.
Giovanni’s on 11th Street is the place to go when everyone is hungry and nobody wants to overthink the order. You’ll find their familiar crust, well-loaded toppings, and a buffet that makes it easy to sample a bit of everything. It’s a reliable choice for teams, church groups, or extended family meetups after a game or event.
04
Family-pleasing pick
Mr Gatti's Pizza
East Portsmouth Near The Highway • Family Pizza Buffet And Arcade-Style Spot • Best For Families
A family-oriented pizza buffet where kids can fill their plates and stay entertained while adults relax.
Mr Gatti’s leans into the fun side of pizza night, with plenty of kid-friendly options and a steady flow of hot pies on the buffet. Parents appreciate that picky eaters can go back for exactly what they like, while adults can grab a salad and a few different slices. It’s a natural pick for birthday gatherings or an easy weekend treat after running errands in town.
05
Custom-slice specialist
Rapid Fired Pizza
New Boston Retail Strip • Fast-Casual Build-Your-Own Spot • Quick Customizable Stop
A modern counter-service pizzeria where you design your own pie and it comes out of the oven in just a few minutes.
When you’re driving in from West Portsmouth and want something quick but not drive-thru fast food, Rapid Fired hits the sweet spot. You walk the line, choose your crust, sauce, and toppings, and your personal pizza is baked in about the time it takes to grab a drink. It’s especially handy for mixed-diet groups, since everyone can tailor their own pizza exactly how they like it.