01
Best in-town slice
Wyse Guys Restaurant & Pizzeria
In West Unity • Small-Town Pizzeria And Family Restaurant • Go-To Local Favorite
Casual, friendly, and reliably cheesy, Wyse Guys is the pizza place most West Unity locals think of first.
Right on the main drag in West Unity, Wyse Guys serves the kind of straightforward, saucy pies that work for just about any night of the week. The crust is on the thicker side with plenty of cheese, and toppings are piled generously without getting fussy. It is an easy choice when you want to stay in town and still feel like you treated yourself.
02
Classic pan pizza
Pisanello's Pizza
Downtown Bryan • Old-School Pan And Hand-Tossed Pizza Shop • Best For Loaded Specialty Pies
Pisanello's in Bryan leans into hearty, cheesy pan pizzas with plenty of classic Midwest charm.
Set near the heart of downtown Bryan, Pisanello's is the spot for thick, golden-edged crust and heavy-on-the-toppings combos. The menu runs deep with specialties, from meat-heavy options to veggie-forward pies, plus familiar sides like breadsticks and wings. It is ideal when you want a filling pizza night that still feels like a small-town original rather than a chain.
03
Local legend
Vince's Pizza
North Bryan Neighborhood • Family-Run Pizzeria With Dine-In And Carryout • Best For Families And Groups
Vince's serves generous, shareable pies in a down-to-earth setting that has the feel of a long-running local standby.
Vince's is the kind of place where big pizzas land in the middle of the table and everyone digs in. Crusts are sturdy enough to hold lots of toppings, and the sauce skews savory rather than sweet, which keeps even loaded slices balanced. With a relaxed dining room and friendly staff, it is a solid choice for post-game team outings or an easy family dinner.
04
Chain comfort pick
Marco's Pizza
Bryan Shopping Strip • National Chain With Consistent, Customizable Pies • Best For Fast Delivery And Coupons
Marco's in Bryan delivers exactly what you expect from the brand: reliable, customizable pizzas that show up hot at your door.
If you are coming back late on a weeknight or feeding a crowd on short notice, Marco's is the dependable fallback. You can build your own pizza with different crust styles and sauces, or lean on their familiar specialty combos and thick-cut pepperoni. Regular deals and online ordering make it especially practical for larger orders and last-minute cravings.
05
Worth-the-drive grinder & pie spot
Samuel Mancino's Italian Eatery
Archbold Commercial Strip • Italian Eatery Known For Grinders And Thick-Crust Pizza • Best For A Hearty Sit-Down Meal
Samuel Mancino's in Archbold pairs hefty pizzas with their signature oven-baked grinders for a full Italian-comfort spread.
About a short drive east of West Unity, Samuel Mancino's rewards the trip with chewy, substantial crusts and plenty of cheese. Many locals split a pizza and one of the shop's toasted grinders, turning a simple pizza stop into a full meal. It is a relaxed, sit-down option when you have a little extra time and want something more than grab-and-go.