01
Best overall pick
Cardinal Pizza Shop
Uptown Westerville • Craft-Leaning Pizzeria And Taproom • Local Favorite For Balanced Pies
Cardinal Pizza Shop is the go-to in Uptown for thoughtfully topped pies and a relaxed, neighborhood feel.
Cardinal leans into carefully balanced pizzas rather than sheer size, with toppings that feel intentional instead of piled on. The crust lands in that sweet spot between chewy and crisp, and the menu has plenty of combinations that work for both adventurous and plain eaters. It’s an easy choice when you want something a notch above standard delivery without losing that casual, local vibe.
02
Coziest dine-in
Minico's Italian Restaurant
County Line Road • Cozy Red-Sauce Italian Restaurant • Best For Laid-Back Family Dinners
Minico’s serves classic, sauce-forward pizzas in a snug, old-school dining room where families linger over extra slices.
The pies at Minico’s feel like the kind you grew up eating, with a slightly thicker crust, lots of cheese, and a tomato sauce regulars rave about. It’s the kind of place where you order a large for the table, add a salad and maybe some pasta, and settle in for a slow, unhurried meal. If you want comfort-food pizza with a friendly, neighborhood feel, this is an easy recommendation.
03
Most reliable takeout
Classic Pizza
North State Street Corridor • Old-School Mom-And-Pop Slice Shop • Best For Quick Takeout And Delivery
Classic Pizza is the no-nonsense local shop you call when you want hot, cheesy pies on the table fast.
Classic Pizza leans into the basics and does them well: sturdy crust, plenty of cheese, and toppings that feel generously scattered edge to edge. It’s a hit for busy weeknights, kids’ sleepovers, and game days when you don’t want to overthink the order. Expect straightforward flavors, friendly service, and pies that hold up for a second round later in the night.
04
Best for feeding a crowd
Gionino's Pizzeria
Westerville Plaza Corridor • Regional Chain Pizzeria • Best Value For Big Orders
Gionino’s delivers big, crowd-pleasing pizzas with plenty of toppings and combo deals that make large orders painless.
This regional favorite is built for volume without feeling generic, with pizzas that are substantial, cheesy, and easy to customize. The menu leans into hearty specialty pies and extras like wings, so you can cover a range of tastes with one call. It’s especially useful when you’re feeding a team, hosting a watch party, or just need a lot of food without blowing the budget.
05
Best sit-down experience
Giammarco's Italian Restaurant
Schrock Road Corridor • Lively Italian Bar And Grill • Best For Groups And Date Night
Giammarco’s pairs well-made pizzas with a full Italian menu, making it an easy upgrade from basic pizza night.
Pizzas at Giammarco’s share the stage with pasta and entrees, but they hold their own with nicely browned cheese and flavorful toppings. It’s a great pick when some of the table wants pizza and others are eyeing chicken parm or a big bowl of pasta. The lively bar, roomy dining area, and patio in good weather make it a strong choice for group dinners or low-key date nights.