01
Best overall pick
Courthouse Pizzeria
Medina Public Square • New York-Style Slice Shop • Local Favorite
A bustling spot on the square serving big, foldable New York-style slices and whole pies with plenty of character.
If you’re willing to make the quick drive from Westfield Center, Courthouse Pizzeria feels like the classic small-town slice shop you wish you had on your own corner. The crust is thin with just enough chew, toppings are generous, and you can order by the slice if you’re wandering the square. It’s an easy go-to before events on the green or after an afternoon exploring Medina’s historic center.
02
For regional Ohio style
Ohio Valley Pizza Co.
North Medina • Ohio Valley-Style Pan Pizza Shop • Destination For Pizza Fans
A small operation specializing in Ohio Valley-style pies with airy crusts, edge-to-edge toppings, and cheese piled high.
Ohio Valley Pizza Co. leans into its regional roots, turning out square-cut pies with a light, bready crust and toppings that reach every corner. The style lands somewhere between classic pan pizza and something uniquely its own, which makes it a fun detour for pizza lovers who’ve tried it all. Call ahead on busy nights; regulars know to plan for a bit of a wait when the ovens are full.
03
Cozy Italian night out
Santo Suosso's Pizza Pasta Vino
Route 42 Corridor • Sit-Down Italian Restaurant With Pizza • Best For Date Night
A warmly lit Italian dining room where the pizza shares the spotlight with pasta, wine, and long conversations.
Santo Suosso's is where Medina locals head when they want pizza but also want a proper sit-down meal. The pies come with a slightly thicker, flavorful crust and classic toppings, but you can round things out with antipasti, pasta, and a glass of wine. It’s a relaxed, linger-over-dinner kind of place that works just as well for a low-key date as it does for out-of-town guests from Westfield Center.
04
Reliable crowd-pleaser
Antonio's Pizza
South Medina Shopping Strip • Family-Friendly Regional Chain Pizzeria • Best For Big Groups And Takeout
A go-to stop for hearty, topping-loaded pies, wings, and subs that can feed a carload of kids after games or events.
Antonio's brings the comfort of a well-run regional chain: consistent pies, quick service, and a menu broad enough to keep everyone happy. Crusts are on the sturdy side, built to hold plenty of cheese and toppings, which makes these pizzas ideal for sharing at home back in Westfield Center. It’s the safe, satisfying choice when you’re ordering for a crowd and don’t want to overthink it.
05
Old-school neighborhood spot
Dominic's Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant
East Medina Neighborhood • Classic Neighborhood Italian Pizzeria • Cozy Family Dinner Pick
A down-to-earth Italian spot where the pizza tastes like it’s been made the same way for decades—in a good way.
Dominic's leans into the red-sauce-Italian comfort zone, with pizzas that pair perfectly with a basket of garlic bread and a side of spaghetti. The crust is straightforward and satisfying, the sauce is on the savory side, and the whole experience feels pleasantly unhurried. It’s the kind of place where staff remember regulars, and families from nearby towns like Westfield Center don’t mind driving in for a familiar, low-key meal.