01
Best overall pick
Beer Barrel Pizza & Grill
West Side Of Lima • Lively Family Pizza And Grill • Local Favorite For Groups
Big, shareable pies and a full menu make Beer Barrel worth the short drive from Westminster.
Beer Barrel is the kind of place where you can bring a whole crew and still see the game from your table. The pizzas lean hearty, with generous toppings, plenty of cheese, and a choice of crusts that hold up well for sharing. It’s an easy go-to when you want pizza, wings, apps, and a busy, upbeat dining room all in one stop.
02
Classic local slice
Fat Jack's Pizza
East Lima Toward Westminster • Old-School Takeout Pizzeria • Best Quick Carryout
Thin, edge-to-edge toppings and friendly service define Fat Jack's local following.
Fat Jack's is a straightforward, no-fuss shop that focuses on well-loaded pies and fast turnaround. Crusts are on the thinner, crispier side, with toppings spread right out to the edge in classic Ohio style. It’s a smart pick when you’re heading back to Westminster with a hot box in the passenger seat.
03
College-town favorite
Padrone's Pizza of Ada
Near Ohio Northern University, Ada • Casual College-Town Pie Shop • Top Late-Night Option
Hearty specialty pies and subs keep students and locals coming back to Padrone's in Ada.
Padrone's feels like a classic campus-adjacent pizzeria, with big specialty pies and plenty of cheesy sides. The menu leans bold—think loaded meats, extra cheese, and thick-cut toppings that make each slice a meal. If you’re in Ada for a game or a visit to ONU, it’s an easy, laid-back spot to end the night.
04
Reliable delivery pick
Marco's Pizza
Lima South Side • Delivery-Focused Chain Spot • Most Dependable Delivery
When you want consistent, hot pizza without leaving the house, Marco's is a safe bet.
Marco's leans into customization, from crust and sauce styles to a long list of toppings and extras. The pizzas travel well, with sturdy crusts and plenty of flavor left by the time you get back to Westminster. Add in cheesy bread, wings, and salads, and it’s a solid all-around delivery order for busy weeknights.
05
Nostalgic dine-in
Pizza Hut
Lima East Corridor • Casual Sit-Down Chain • Best For A Laid-Back Family Night
Familiar pan crust and roomy booths make this Pizza Hut an easy family choice.
If you grew up on thick pan pizza and red-roof chains, this Pizza Hut hits that nostalgic note. The menu runs from classic pepperoni to stuffed-crust splurges, with plenty to keep kids happy. It’s a comfortable, predictable option when you want a sit-down spot not far from the drive back to Westminster.