01
Best overall pick
Ange's Pizza
South Yearling Road • Old-School Columbus-Style Pizzeria • Classic Local Favorite
A longtime Whitehall staple turning out square-cut, Columbus-style pies with a loyal neighborhood following.
If you want a snapshot of classic east-side pizza, start at Ange's. The crust is thin and crisp, the slices are cut tavern-style, and the toppings are generous without getting fussy. It’s the kind of reliable, hometown spot where regulars know their order by heart and carryout boxes disappear quickly on game nights.
02
Best for a pizza night out
Massey's Pizza - Whitehall
Just North Of Whitehall • Casual Dine-In Pizza Pub • Best For Big Groups
A comfortable spot for piling into a booth, sharing loaded pies, and catching the game over pitchers of soda or beer.
Massey’s leans into hearty, topping-heavy pizzas that feel built for sharing. Expect plenty of cheese, crisp-edged pepperoni, and specialty pies that arrive already sliced for easy table grazing. It’s an easy choice when you’ve got a crew to feed and you’d rather grab a booth than juggle a stack of boxes at home.
03
Best big-menu option
Happy's Pizza
East Main Street Strip • Delivery-Focused Pizza And Wings Spot • Late-Night Delivery Pick
A go-to for hefty pizzas, wings, and sides when you need to feed a hungry group without overthinking it.
Happy’s is built for those nights when variety matters as much as the pizza itself. Alongside customizable pies, you’ll find wings, ribs, and plenty of shareable sides, so everyone can get a little of what they’re craving. It’s especially handy for late or last-minute orders when cooking is off the table.
04
Most familiar option
Pizza Hut
Far East Main Street • Family-Friendly National Chain • Reliable Family Dinner Stand-By
The Whitehall outpost of this national staple delivers the pan pizzas, stuffed crusts, and breadsticks everyone already knows.
Sometimes you just want pizza that’s exactly what you expect, and this Pizza Hut fits that bill. Kids gravitate toward the stuffed crust and breadsticks, while adults can lean on the familiar pan and thin-crust pies. It’s a straightforward choice for weeknights, road-trip stops, or any time you want zero surprises with your order.
05
Best quick carryout
Papa Johns Pizza - E. Main St.
Near Bexley Line • Fast Carryout And Delivery Chain • Best For Quick Carryout
A nearby Main Street location offering fast, consistent pizzas with the familiar garlic sauce and pepperoncini on the side.
Just a short drive from Whitehall, this Papa Johns is a handy option when you need something hot and ready in minutes. The dough has a soft, bready chew, toppings are straightforward, and the included garlic butter and pepperoncini give each order a little extra character. It’s ideal for last-minute weeknight dinners or quick pickups between errands.