01
Best overall pick
The Brick Oven Bistro
Near Downtown Sandusky • Brick-Oven Pizza And Italian Bistro • Local Favorite
Thin, crisp brick-oven pies, hearty toppings, and a cozy dining room make this Sandusky staple worth the drive from Whites Landing.
The Brick Oven Bistro is the spot locals recommend first when someone asks where to get really good pizza around the bay. Their brick-oven crust has just enough chew and char to stand up to generous toppings, and the menu balances classic combos with more creative builds. It works equally well for a relaxed date night or a family dinner after a day on the water.
02
Best for families
Chet & Matt's Pizza
East Sandusky • High-Energy Family Pizza Restaurant • Best For Big Groups
A lively, sports-themed spot known for big specialty pies, buffet-style options, and an easygoing, kid-friendly feel.
Chet & Matt's is built for teams, birthday parties, and any crew that rolls in hungry. Pizzas come in crowd-pleasing sizes with plenty of cheese and toppings, and the casual, sports-bar energy makes it simple to relax, linger, and let kids be kids. If you are staying near Cedar Point or in east Sandusky, it is one of the most convenient, low-stress choices for a group meal.
03
Classic carryout choice
Pizza Brothers
South Sandusky • Neighborhood Carryout And Delivery Pizzeria • Takeout Staple
Old-school, no-frills pies with reliable delivery make this a go-to when you want good pizza back at the house or cottage.
Pizza Brothers on Columbus Avenue has the feel of a long-running local shop: straightforward crust, plenty of cheese, and familiar toppings done right. It is an easy pick for takeout on your way back through town, and the delivery radius is handy if you are staying south of the bay or along the main routes. Order a couple of specialty pizzas and some wings and you are set for a relaxed night in.
04
Best for craft beer and pizza
Small City Taphouse
Downtown Sandusky • Craft-Beer Bar With Creative Pizzas And Asian Fusion • Best For A Night Out
Known for its huge tap list and eclectic menu, this downtown hangout also turns out surprisingly good pizzas to go with the beer.
Small City Taphouse draws people downtown for its wall of taps and busy, social atmosphere, but the pizza holds its own. The crust is on the thinner side, with toppings that lean more adventurous than traditional, making it a fun option if your group likes to share and sample. It is an ideal stop if you want a place that feels more like a night out than a basic pizza run.
05
Best nearby small-town spot
Papa Jimmy’s Pizzeria
Castalia • Small-Town Pizzeria • Cozy Local Pick
A low-key Castalia shop that serves straightforward, generously topped pies just a short drive from Whites Landing.
If you would rather stay closer to the back roads than head all the way into Sandusky, Papa Jimmy’s in Castalia is a handy option. It leans into the classic small-town pizza formula: familiar toppings, friendly service, and fair prices, with plenty of locals coming in for carryout. It is a good fit for a casual, no-fuss dinner after a day exploring the creeks and back bays near Whites Landing.