01
Best overall pick
Petti's Pizza & Ristorante
Euclid Avenue In Wickliffe • Classic Red-Sauce Italian Restaurant • Local Legend
Long-running family spot turning out big, cheesy pies alongside pasta and old-school Italian comfort food.
Petti's has been a Wickliffe standby for decades, and it shows in the confident way they do pizza: sturdy crust, plenty of cheese, and a sauce locals grow up on. You can go thin and crispy or order a heavier, party-ready pie and still expect it to hold up. It is the kind of place where families linger over red-checkered tables while takeout orders fly out the door.
02
Best Sicilian squares
The Original Giuseppe's Pizza & Subs
Just North Of Wickliffe In Willowick • Counter-Service Pizzeria And Sub Shop • Worth-The-Drive Favorite
Beloved for its thick, airy Sicilian square pizzas and hefty subs that travel well.
Giuseppe's is the spot people mention when they talk about those hefty, pan-baked square pizzas with crisp edges and a soft, bready middle. The slightly sweet sauce and generous cheese make each corner piece a prize. Call ahead for larger orders, because locals know to snag a sheet pizza here for birthdays, team parties, and Sunday gatherings.
03
Most reliable chain
Pizza Hut
Euclid Avenue Strip In Wickliffe • National Pizza Chain Carryout And Delivery • Fast And Reliable
Go-to choice when you want familiar pan pizza, breadsticks, and wings without overthinking it.
The Wickliffe Pizza Hut is a workhorse for weeknights, kids' sleepovers, and big game days when you just need a stack of boxes on the table. The menu is exactly what you expect: pan and hand-tossed pies, stuffed crust splurges, and plenty of sauces for wings and breadsticks. Order online, grab one of the frequent deals, and dinner is handled in a single stop.
04
Best value carryout
Capps Pizza
Near Shoregate In Willowick • Casual Neighborhood Carryout Shop • Best Value Slices
Straightforward Northeast Ohio-style pizza with plenty of cheese, generous toppings, and wallet-friendly specials.
Capps is the sort of low-key spot people around Wickliffe rely on when they want solid pizza at a fair price. The pies are cut into crowd-pleasing squares, with toppings spread right to the edge and no skimping on cheese. It is especially handy for last-minute family dinners or feeding a hungry group after a game without blowing the budget.
05
Best for creative toppings
Master Pizza
Euclid Avenue Corridor In Willoughby • Modern Craft-Pizza Spot • Game-Day Go-To
Offers a mix of classic pies and more adventurous topping combinations on reliably crisp crusts.
Master Pizza brings a slightly more modern edge to the local pizza mix, with specialty pies and build-your-own options that reward experimenting. You can keep it simple with pepperoni or branch out into loaded combinations without losing that sturdy, football-Sunday-friendly crust. Add an order of wings and you are set up for an easy night in just a short drive from Wickliffe.