01
Best overall pick
Valley Pizza Co.
Near Bolivar • Casual Hometown Pizzeria • Go-To Carryout For Wilkshire Hills
A reliable, generously topped pizza that feels made for weeknight carryout and game-day orders.
Valley Pizza Co. hits that sweet spot of well-made dough, plenty of cheese, and classic toppings done right. It is close enough to Wilkshire Hills that locals treat it as their default pizza night option, especially when they do not feel like driving into the bigger towns. Expect friendly, small-town service and pizzas that reheat well the next day.
02
Classic Tuscarawas County institution
Pangrazio's Pizza & Spaghetti House
Dover • Old-School Italian-American Pizzeria • Best For Big Groups And Families
A long-running Dover favorite known for its hearty pies, red-sauce comfort food, and relaxed dining room.
Pangrazio's is the kind of place where families have been ordering the same pizza for decades. The crust leans classic rather than trendy, with a slightly chewy base that can stand up to plenty of toppings and extra cheese. It is worth the short drive from Wilkshire Hills when you want sit-down pizza, a plate of pasta, and enough leftovers to take home.
03
Worth-the-drive pies
Park Street Pizza
Sugarcreek • Wood-Fired And Farm-Focused Pizzeria • Best For Food-Focused Pizza Night
Creative, wood-fired pizzas with quality ingredients that feel more like a destination meal than a quick slice.
Park Street Pizza has earned a regional following for its careful toppings, crisped edges, and slightly blistered crusts. The menu leans seasonal and a bit adventurous, so it is a smart pick when you are in the mood to try specialty combinations instead of just pepperoni. Plan on a little extra drive time from Wilkshire Hills and treat it as a night out rather than a last-minute carryout run.
04
Most convenient chain option
East of Chicago Pizza
Bolivar Area • Casual Chain With Pan And Thin Crusts • Best For Customizable Orders
A familiar regional chain that offers a wide range of crusts, sauces, and toppings for group orders.
For nights when convenience matters most, East of Chicago near Bolivar is an easy choice from Wilkshire Hills. The menu covers everything from thick, sauce-forward pan pies to lighter thin-crust options, plus wings and sides to round out a big order. It is especially handy when you are feeding a crowd that all want something a little different on their pizza.
05
Canton-style favorite
Pizza Oven
Canton South • Thick-Crust Regional Chain • Best For Loaded, Shareable Pies
A beloved Stark County mini-chain known for thick, cheesy pizzas piled high with toppings.
Pizza Oven is a Canton-area standby that many Wilkshire Hills residents are willing to drive for, especially on weekends. The pizzas are substantial, with a soft yet sturdy crust and a heavy hand on both cheese and toppings, making each box feel like it can feed more people than you expect. Call ahead at busy times, pick up on your way back down I-77, and you will have a hot, crowd-pleasing pie ready for the table.