01
Small-town staple
Rayz Café
Downtown Genoa, About 10 Minutes South Of Williston • Small-Town Bar And Pizza Joint • Small-Town Staple
Lively Genoa hangout known for generously topped pizzas, wings, and friendly service.
This is the kind of place where the staff knows regulars by name and a big pizza feeds a table of hungry families or softball teams. The crust is sturdy enough for heavy toppings, and their specialty pies come loaded with cheese and meats. Come for a relaxed, small-town night out and stay for another round while your pizza bakes.
02
Best for quick takeout
Marco's Pizza – Oregon
Oregon, Along The Navarre Avenue Strip • Carryout And Delivery Chain Shop • Best For Quick Takeout
Reliable pies with chewy crust and plenty of toppings, easy to grab on the way home from Toledo or the lake.
When you want an easy, no-surprises pizza night, this Oregon location is a dependable option. The menu runs from classic pepperoni to build-your-own combinations, plus wings, subs, and salads for mixed groups. It is a practical choice for weeknights, game days, or feeding a crowd without lingering over a sit-down meal.
03
Best for craft beer and pizza night
Stubborn Brother Pizza Bar
Near The University Of Toledo In West Toledo • College-Town Pizza Bar With Craft Feel • Best For Craft Beer And Pizza Night
Trendy spot turning out crisp, foldable pies with creative toppings and a strong beer list.
If you are up for a fuller night out, this buzzy pizza bar rewards the drive with thin, well-charred crusts and playful topping combos. The room has a lively, brick-and-wood look that works for date night, a friends' meet-up, or a pre-game bite. Pair a specialty pie with a local draft and plan to linger a bit longer than you would at a typical carryout shop.
04
Old-school local favorite
The Original Gino's Pizza
Central Toledo • Classic Toledo-Style Pizzeria • Old-School Local Favorite
Long-running pizzeria serving square-cut pies with a loyal local following.
Gino's leans into classic Midwest pizza: a slightly thicker crust, edge-to-edge cheese, and plenty of pepperoni. Inside, it has the comfortable feel of a long-time neighborhood spot, with booths, big pies on stands, and families sharing baskets of sides. It is a natural pick if you like traditional, no-frills pizza done the way locals have ordered it for decades.
05
Best for loaded specialty pies
Danny's Pizza – Oregon
Residential Side Streets Off Navarre Avenue In Oregon • Neighborhood Carryout And Delivery Shop • Best For Loaded Specialty Pies
Locals swear by the generously cheesed pies and friendly, no-fuss service.
Danny's feels like the kind of neighborhood spot you grow up with, where a couple of specialty pies can anchor any casual get-together. Expect hearty crusts, plenty of toppings, and sauces that lean comfort over trendiness. It is especially handy when you want to support a smaller local operation but still get big, shareable pizzas for the whole group.